Paul McGlasson decided to write his sixth book in August 2011. The presidential campaign was revving up.
A Christian minister, author and Yale-educated theologian, the 56-year-old pastor of First Presbyterian Church in Sullivan felt compelled to answer an event in Texas. The result was McGlasson’s newly released book, “No! A Theological Response to Christian Reconstructionism.”
Conducted at Houston’s Reliant Stadium, the event, called “The Response,” served as the launch of Texas Gov. Rick Perry’s bid for the 2012 Republican Party presidential nomination. In his book, McGlasson describes The Response prayer rally as “a Christians-only effort to call on divine support for Perry’s candidacy, as well as to ‘claim’ the United States for a new Christian transformation in the political realm.”
To McGlasson, the rally at Perry’s campaign launch exemplified the deepening alignment of a Christian movement, often termed the religious right, with one political party. McGlasson decided to challenge the theological basis of Christian reconstructionism, which he views as a set of political-religious ideas or “dominion theology.”
In a political issue, “when politicians or Christians say, ‘This position is the Christian position,’ then as a theologian, my ears prick up,” McGlasson said, sitting in his office at the Sullivan church.
An official with the American Family Association, a Christian group that helped sponsor The Response, defended the alignment with the Republican Party last week and rebutted McGlasson’s assessments.
Now in his 13th year as pastor at Sullivan, McGlasson has authored five other books, including, “God the Redeemer,” “Canon and Proclamation” and “Invitation to Dogmatic Theology.” He and his wife, Peggy, a speech pathologist, have two adult children — one in college at Indiana University and another recently graduated from Ball State and is working as an AmeriCorps volunteer. McGlasson received a master’s of divinity degree from Yale Divinity School and a doctorate in systematic theology from Yale. Prior to his parish ministry, McGlasson taught theology at the college and seminary levels.
“I’m no liberal, in terms of being a Christian,” he explained from his office, while a couple of installers worked on the sound system inside the church’s sanctuary. “I consider myself a mainstream ecumenical Christian.”
In terms of religion and national politics, “The people that are getting all the press are on the extremes,” McGlasson said. In between, he added, are earnest Christians simply trying to discern God’s will for church and society. Whether through Christian reconstructionism on the right, or the religious left, alignments in partisan politics deserve theological challenge, McGlasson contends.
“I don’t think the Gospel can be politicized,” he said, “and politicizing it from either side is a mistake.”
McGlasson sees the growth of Christian reconstructionism on the right shifting from the 1980s Moral Majority efforts for a Christian influence in society to the present-day movement to place Christian dominion over society. “Even a guy like Jerry Falwell didn’t see it quite that dramatically,” McGlasson said, referring to the late co-founder of the Moral Majority.
In his theological response, McGlasson said reconstructionism involves four interconnected ideas — a Christian world view, which he said cultivates “us vs. them” epistemological dualism; that Christians have the right and role to legislate morality for all people everywhere; that Christianity and western culture are two sides of the same coin; and that the ultimate calling of Christians is to dominate the earth.
The global Christian church, McGlasson said, is growing rapidly, especially in Asia and Latin America. Approximately 1 in 4 of the world’s Christians live in sub-Saharan Africa, and about 1 in 8 reside in Asia or the Pacific region, according to the Pew Research Center. Christianity’s global growth, McGlasson said, is the result of service by Christians through the example of Jesus Christ. “He said, I came not to be served but to serve, and that’s the fundamental call to be a Christian — to serve and not be served, especially to the weak and to the helpless, and not to dominate,” McGlasson said.
In his book’s introduction, McGlasson writes that it aims to stress four points, on the basis of Scripture. “First, the inherent value of democracy as a divine right for all peoples and nations; second, the need for economic equality in a world which is becoming increasingly polarized between the wealthy and the poor; third, the embrace of the outsider, the foreigner, the marginalized in our global society; and finally, the relative value of human culture (including government, art, science, education, and so forth) for Christian existence under God’s gracious care. All of these are joined together in a force more powerful than any false quest for dominion over the other, indeed the most powerful force in the world: the power of love. The Christian is called to participate in nothing less than a new society.”
Through an email response to a Tribune-Star query seeking comment, Bryan Fischer, director of issue analysis for the American Family Association, agreed with McGlasson on one point, but disagreed on others. Fischer mentioned particular issues — taxation levels, immigration enforcement, abortion and same-sex marriage — in validating the AFA’s political involvement through referencing Bible passages. He had not read McGlasson’s book.
“I certainly agree with him that moral and economic truth are not the province of any one political party,” Fischer wrote. “But on the other hand, the Democratic platform supports abortion on demand and ‘marriage’ based on the infamous crime against nature. The Republican Party platform endorses the sanctity of human life at all stages of development and one man-one woman marriage, both of them biblical standards. The differences between the two parties on those issues is not political but moral, and it would be foolish and dangerously naive not to recognize that.”
McGlasson offered scriptural basis for his conclusions, too, and challenged using the Bible to fight “an ideological battle between the left and the right.”
McGlasson is not sure what this fall’s election, from the local level to the presidential race between President Obama and Republican nominee Mitt Romney, will do to the future political involvement of the religious right. Christians, he predicted, will later see the trend as a mistake. In the early 20th century, he pointed out, many well-meaning Christians pushed successfully for the national prohibition of alcohol. That ban instituted in 1920, though, was marred by organized crime and unequally applied enforcement, and was repealed in 1933.
The fight against alcoholism was “understandable,” McGlasson said. “Lives were ruined by it. Preaching against alcoholism is a good thing. Preaching against any form of addiction is a good thing. But trying to legislate that on other people is another thing.”
Mark Bennett can be reached at 812-231-4377 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Paul McGlasson decided to write his sixth book in August 2011. The presidential campaign was revving up.
- Valley Life
CHRIS DAVIES: Exercising with no ‘bells and whistles’
Recently at Fitness Solutions the joke has been “treadmills and cardio equipment are broken.” The truth is we don’t have any exercise machines that require electricity. This is for good reason.
MIKE LUNSFORD: The long goodbye to winter
I have no idea what the weather is to bring to us on the morning this story runs, but on the day I write most of it, the sun is shining, and we have just come off a weekend of pleasant warmth and cloudless skies.
GRAPE SENSE: News from the world’s wine regions can affect future prices
News from the world’s wine regions can affect even the average wine drinker. There is a lot going on, particularly in California, which can affect future wine prices.
TRIED ’N’ TRUE: The easiest ham loaf I’ve ever made
I have been asked for a good ham loaf recipe. This is really good. It comes from a friend of mine in Morton, Ill. Eileen Knapp makes this for her kids and grandkids — we all enjoyed it.
ANNIVERSARY: March 2, 2014
Mr. and Mrs. Jerry Morris
Making Waves: Woman devotes part of rural Vigo County home to museum on hairstyling
Some studies show that women spend more than $50,000 in a lifetime and more than one month of their entire life at a beauty salon, trying to get and keep their hair just the right style. How they have accomplished this through the ages has been a fascination for local hairstylist Brenda Ellis for more than 50 years.
TRIED ‘N’ TRUE: No need to knead dough much for these rolls
I know we all like homemade bread. These rolls are great.
When we used to have Christmas with Gene’s family, his uncle Bob Beard’s daughter made these Oatmeal Rolls.
YOUR GREEN VALLEY: We can help save the manatees, right here in the heartland
The year 2013 was the deadliest on record for manatees with about 829 reported deaths. This was a major jump from the 392 in 2012 and the record of 766 in 2010. While the cold weather played a role, one major attributing factor has been toxic red tide events caused by algal blooms.
Rockville Library to dedicate genealogy collection March 8
The genealogy collection at the Rockville Public Library will be named for Alberta T. Butler in a celebration at 1 p.m. on March 8. Butler was a longtime board member of the library, member of the Parke County Historical Society and member of the Wabash Valley Genealogical Society. She died July 24, 2013.
Planning Your Farm’s Future program March 4
As commercial farms grow in size and business risk becomes more magnified, farm families are thinking more and more about how the family farm will operate in future years, as well as who will provide management and who will control farm assets.
Engagement listings: Feb. 23, 2014
Wedding listing: Feb. 23, 2014
Anniversary listing: Feb. 23, 2014
Mr. and Mrs. Vernon Richey
Brenda Ellis devotes part of her rural Vigo County home to a museum on hairstyling. See story by Marjorie Hopkins and more photos by Jim Avelis in Sunday's Valley Life and on tribstar.com.
Heaven on Earth: Writer gets lost — both figuratively and literally — at Acadia National Park
Editor’s Note: Today, we continue the New England Journal as Mike Lunsford writes of a day hiking the Atlantic shoreline and the trails of Maine’s Acadia National Park.
GRAPE SENSE: The rare but exciting 100 percent Sagrantino wine
It’s easy to buy a big, expensive California Cabernet, red Bordeaux or Oregon Pinot Noir for an intimate dinner party or special gift. But to really surprise a serious wine lover or yourself, why not try something really different?
TRIED ‘N’ TRUE: A nutritious, delicious after-school snack
We are always looking for something good and easy to give to the kids when they get home from school. I know I always was.
When grandkids came along they would help me make all kinds of bars. This recipe is from Pam from Sullivan Extension.
Women’s Only Wellness Weekend coming up April 4-6
The inaugural Women’s Only Wellness Weekend at Turkey Run State Park this spring offers a chance for women to hike beautiful trails, enjoy the food and accommodations of the Turkey Run Inn, and participate in workshops ranging from photography to bird-watching to wine tasting.
Anniversary listings: Feb. 16, 2014
Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Blacketer
Mr. and Mrs. Richard J. Buck
Rock of Ages: Hulman Center stage has been entertaining crowds since 1974
As the stage lights came on, Sam Wellington and his cohorts gazed out at an audience of 8,060 Midwesterners.
The scene was familiar for him. Wellington and his country music quartet, The Four Guys, opened shows night after night for fellow RCA Records artists Ronnie Millsap and headliner Charley Pride on tours across North America.
CANDLES to show film on ‘British Schindler’
The film, “Nicky’s Family,” will be shown at 5:30 pm. on Feb. 20 in the CANDLES Holocaust Museum and Education Center at 1532 S. Third St. Admission is free. Pizza will be served at 5 p.m.
TRIED ‘N’ TRUE: A quick pork chop recipe to throw in the oven
At this time of year we need something quick. We go to work and we want to make something for our loved ones.
You can make this for two, four, six or however many loved ones you may have.
Chris Davies: Educators take Fitness Challenge
Beginning in 2014 many made New Year’s resolutions. Ten area educators took a challenge that is having them shed weight, get fit and raise money for two great organizations.
Wearing a Legacy: Inspired by Debs, a variety of places and things beyond Terre Haute — from a town to beers — bear his name
A town and a school. Two styles of beer. A radio station, a street, a township, and a house for college students. Even a parade.
Any of those places or things named in honor of legendary labor and social activist Eugene V. Debs could theoretically exist in Terre Haute. Alas, none do.
GRAPE SENSE: Lenore Syrah, possibly the best value wine I’ve tasted in years
The past seven years this column has focused mostly on great wines under $20 that you won’t find on the grocery shelf. Every time it seems like the list is exhausted, another wine comes along to make even the wine cynic say ‘wow!’
TRIED ‘N’ TRUE: An Italian chicken recipe that’s easy to make
This recipe comes from one of my readers who wanted to remain anonymous. Their grandparents made this chicken all the time, especially when family or friends dropped by their home.
Flowing forward: As Riverscape leader retires, he sees great things ahead for the Wabash River
An iconic photo of Harry Truman hangs in John Mutchner’s office.
The walls of that room and others inside Mutchner’s scenic eastside home offer glimpses of his interests, from auto racing to basketball to political history. The famous picture of a triumphant Truman, hoisting an erroneous “Dewey Defeats Truman” Chicago Tribune headline, rests neatly framed alongside a 1952 campaign button and an autographed notecard from the former president.
YOUR GREEN VALLEY: Bird feeder ignites passion for feathered friends in 15-year-old
In a dimly lit room, avid bird watchers gather for the annual Wabash Valley Audubon Society Photo Night at the Vigo County Public Library. One by one, presenters flipped through their photos to show off unique birds they saw throughout the year. When a presenter is stumped on the identification of a bird they photographed, the crowd works together to identify the bird. One photo in particular took these veteran birders longer than average to call out the identification.
TRIED ‘N’ TRUE: A really good chocolate chip cake recipe
Last September, I bought two cookbooks from Dunlap Methodist Church, one for me and one for my grandson, Tyler, who wants to be a chef. I told him the best cookbooks are ones from churches and different organizations. They have been tried.
CASY plans Orientation I, II trainings Feb. 4, 22
Chances and Services for Youth, or CASY, provides Orientation I training for those interested in becoming a licensed child care provider. Orientation I is part one of two trainings on opening a child care site. It is a start-up workshop for those interested in opening a Licensed Family Child Care Home, Licensed Child Care Center or Unlicensed Registered Ministry.
- More Valley Life Headlines
- CHRIS DAVIES: Exercising with no ‘bells and whistles’