TERRE HAUTE —
Hempstead sounds like a fine place.
Founded in 1644 by European settlers, some say they named the town after its primary farm crop — hemp. Today, Hempstead houses the headquarters of Swiss International and Lufthansa airlines. Hofstra University calls that New York community its home. So did Dr. J, as a kid, for a couple of years.
No offense to Hempstead, but the ideal setting for Tuesday’s town hall style presidential debate is not the Hofstra campus, where it will indeed occur.
Terre Haute would be the perfect location.
In fact, Terre Haute should host one of the debates every four years. The leaders of the local four-year colleges — Indiana State University, Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology and Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College — would do America a favor by coordinating efforts to bring a 2016 presidential debate to one of their scenic campuses. No place serves as a better barometer of the nation’s desires in the presidential selection process than Vigo County and its county seat, Terre Haute.
As Vigo County goes, so goes the United States, at least on Election Day.
The county’s status as an electoral bellwether is amazing. Since 1888, the majority of Vigo Countians have voted for the winning presidential candidate in every election except two — 1908 and 1952 — and those two misses came by razor-thin margins, according to statistics compiled by election historian Dave Leip. In ’52, Adlai Stevenson of neighboring Illinois carried Vigo County by 35 votes over Republican Dwight Eisenhower, who won the presidency in a landslide. Just 18 voting switches to Ike would’ve kept the county’s record perfect going back to 1908. In that election, Vigo voters gave loquacious Democrat William Jennings Bryan a 462-vote edge over William Howard Taft. (Full names were in vogue that year.) Like Eisenhower, Taft routed Bryan in the national balloting.
Aside from those two aberrations, Vigo County has mirrored America, including historic 2008. No other county comes close.
“Vigo is a standout,” Leip said in an email response last week.
As a result, national, and even international, journalists have journeyed to Terre Haute in advance of presidential elections, hoping to find the formula inside the local crystal ball, especially in 2008. The Italian daily newspaper Il Sole 24 Ore sent correspondent Mario Margiocco to Vigo County in late October. The eyes of an outsider often reveal realities overlooked by locals.
“In the United States, there are many nice places,” he said in a visit to the Tribune-Star newsroom, “and the Midwest might not be the nicest one, but it is the more interesting one; the real heart of the country. If I can, I want to feel the mood.”
By contrast, Margiocco noted that voters in Manhattan in New York have backed the losing candidate in 60 percent of the elections. “Since 1928, Manhattan has always voted for [what] we call ‘progressive’ [candidates], because they never change their opinion,” he said, “but you do here.”
That’s the secret — Vigo Countians are open-minded. Who knew?
Of course, that suggestion might come as a shock to former residents who left this community because “Terre Haute never changes.” And, they have a point. Lord knows, resistance to the C-word here is legendary, in some respects. The Terre Haute House decayed before our eyes for nearly 40 years, at the very heart of the city, but eventually, positive change happened.
Vigo County should celebrate its reputation for political open-mindedness and accuracy.
The 2008 election exemplifies the community’s unique outlook. That year, 52.9 percent of American voters chose Democrat Barack Obama over Republican John McCain, and Obama’s Electoral College edge was 365 to 173. He picked up Indiana’s 11 Electoral votes by narrowly winning the state, 49.9 percent to McCain’s 48.9 — the first Democrat to take the Hoosier state since LBJ in 1964. Only 15 Hoosier counties favored Obama, but most were in the metropolitan and college communities. Of those, only five were south of Interstate 70 — Vigo, Monroe, Vanderburgh, Spencer and Perry.
Even though Obama led national polls late in that campaign, some political insiders wondered whether Vigo County’s bellwether string would end. Obama, the first major-party black candidate, would need lots of support from white voters to carry the county — a place that’s not immune to, or devoid of, pockets of racism, not unlike many small American cities.
The county proved its bellwether mettle again.
Obama took Vigo County by a 15.8-percent margin, receiving 57 percent of the vote here, exceeding both the national and statewide spreads. His two visits to Terre Haute won over voters who might otherwise have backed his rival. “He spent a lot of time here, and that mattered,” said Tom Steiger, a sociology professor at Indiana State University, who has conducted polls of local voters in past elections.
Vigo’s bellwether label will be sternly tested again this November. The president and Republican challenger Mitt Romney stand basically even in the national polls going into their town hall debate Tuesday night at Hempstead. Though economic signs are improving, with the unemployment rate and claims for jobless benefits at four-year lows, Vigo County’s unemployment rate of 9.8 percent tops the state and national levels. If voters here blame Obama for the bleak local numbers, he could lose the county even if he retains the presidency nationally.
Vigo, though, also contains the mix of labor and working-class people, alongside the college communities, several minorities and ethnic groups, rural and urban, and the poverty-stricken and middle-class, as well as some wealthy. Thus, as the record indicates, predicting the county’s presidential voting is never as simple as a single statistic. In fact, until Romney surprised Obama with an aggressive performance in their first debate on Oct. 3, the president appeared to have the upperhand here, said Joe Anderson, a Terre Haute attorney, longtime political observer and Democratic Party insider.
“If we had the election the day before the debate, I think Obama would’ve won this county,” Anderson said.
Ten days later, the forecast is less clear. The upcoming debates, on Tuesday and Oct. 22 at Lynn University in Boca Raton, Fla., may tip wavering local independents. And they are swayable, more so than any other town in the US of A.
“Vigo County resembles, in a microcosm, America, a little better,” Steiger said.
Looking even broader, “Desiderata” poet Max Ehrmann called Terre Haute “the world in miniature.”
The world should come to America’s microcosm in 2016 with a presidential debate.
Mark Bennett can be reached at 812-231-4377 or email@example.com.
TERRE HAUTE —
Hempstead sounds like a fine place.
- Opinion Columns
RONN MOTT: Seeds from the same tree
Mahatma Gandhi, who was born in India before the turn of the 20th Century, went to England to study law and decided to settle in South Africa, and he did for 20 years. His work in South Africa was involved in the right of his Indian neighbors to have equal access to civil rights. He also worked for the indigenous people as well. When the people of India became restive during the early days of World War I, Gandhi came home.
MS. TAKES: Important date passes by without much notice
Recently we were asked to share our memories of the Kennedy assassination. Folks were interviewed for television or radio, or were asked to recall exactly what they were doing when they got word that our president had been murdered.
RONN MOTT: A friend celebrates his 90th
I went to Charlie Fox’s 90th birthday party Sunday last. He was standing greeting people as they came in the door. I never saw him sit down even one time. He looked more like a man celebrating his 60th rather than his 90th.
RONN MOTT: Cigars
Leaving Baesler’s Market the other day, making my round of errands, I started to re-light my cigar. It was left over from the day before and I did not place it in the humidor. It had gotten too dry, so I threw it into my garbage sack asking myself the question, “Why do I do this?” Well, I do it because I enjoy it.
MARK BENNETT: Walk of Fame inductee would stand tall in any era
Unlike most of us, Amory Kinney didn’t let the wall around his comfort zone grow taller as time passed.
RONN MOTT: Cats, Inc.
I suppose we should give her a cake and a candle, but she would be happier with a handful of “treats” you can find wherever you shop for groceries. I’m talking about the two-year anniversary of the first cat we adopted. If we had known there were going to be more, her name probably would have been different. She was Orange Crush, a small, bedraggled, starving, Golden Tabby female that wandered into our yard a little after Thanksgiving. She had been badly maltreated.
MS. TAKES: Plenty of downsides to tree with candlelight
I had been spinning my wheels over Thanksgiving preparations the other day, so my Best Friend took me out for breakfast — a little luxury I never tire of. Our friend, Bill, stopped by our table to offer holiday felicitations and the conversation turned, as it often does this time of year, to Christmas.
LIZ CIANCONE: Plenty of downsides to tree with candlelight
I had been spinning my wheels over Thanksgiving preparations the other day, so my Best Friend took me out for breakfast — a little luxury I never tire of.
MARK BENNETT: ABA’s record proves Bobby Leonard’s a legit Hall of Famer
Bobby Leonard symbolized the feisty competitive flair of the old ABA.
RONN MOTT: Collett Park Christmas Walk always a special event
Since I live right across the street from Collett Park, I enjoy very much this particular neighborhood. And since I have walked around it a few times, I’m familiar with the 0.8 of a mile it takes to walk around the park. The Christmas Walk is a walk around the neighborhood. There were approximately 15 homes involved and open to the public this year
RONN MOTT: Rule Changes
Watching the beginning of a new basketball season reminds me of my attempt to play basketball in high school. On the B-team, at a township high school my freshman and sophomore years, I fouled out of a great many basketball games.
RONN MOTT: A Hornet’s Nest
I seem to have kicked over a hornet’s nest in my criticism of the American health care system.
The basic fact of the matter is this: We do not have, in America, the highest-rated health care system. We are not in the top 10, nor top 20, but somewhere in the middle 30s. Yet we pay more for our health care than any other nation in the world.
LIZ CIANCONE: Mourning a death is a personal exercise
One does not properly “celebrate” an assassination, but it certainly doesn’t hurt to be reminded that there are a lot of nuts out there. Coverage this past week of the anniversary of the Kennedy assassination still has the power to disturb, but all the theories won’t undo the facts.
MARK BENNETT: Letter from coach’s young daughter put pro sports, Christmas in perspective
Most of us sympathize with people forced to work on Thanksgiving and Christmas.
That list is growing, now that Black Friday has morphed into Black Thursday, causing retail employees to join doctors, nurses, hospital staffers, police, firefighters, emergency responders, military members, convenience store clerks, road crews and media to spend holidays at work. Ideally, we’ll feel gratitude when we require their services on those special days. Too often, their sacrificed time gets taken for granted.
Terry Leonard wanted the executives to remember her dad, and their family, at Christmastime.
And, amazingly, they listened.
THOMAS L. STEIGER: Cultural tendencies are what unite and divide us
For the last 10 days a story has been circulating on the Internet adapted from the original source in Tufts Magazine.
Ronn Mott: Memories of long ago Thanksgivings
Like many youngsters growing up in this part of Indiana, the holidays were always something full of good times and, of course, going to Grandma’s house.
RONN MOTT: I remember
Someone said the other day everyone remembers where they were the day John Kennedy was shot. I certainly do.
RONN MOTT: Too Much
I’ve been very fortunate, so far, in my lifetime. I’ve not been hit with any major disease that could, ultimately, kill me. I’ve only been under the knife twice and neither operation was life threatening … tonsils and a kidney stone too large to extract in a normal way.
LIZ CIANCONE: The greatest invention ever? Frozen orange juice
We were talking the other day and someone posed the question: “What do you think has been the greatest invention of all time?”
Larry’s Lessons: On a beautiful fall day at Hulman Center
I attended the unveiling of the Larry Bird statue on Saturday, Nov. 9, and found the proceedings to be wonderful.
RONN MOTT: 95th
Nov. 7, 1918, was a few days before the war to end all wars actually ended. It was 95 years ago. The last veteran who fought in that war has passed away. The growth America took after that war also has passed away and so did Prohibition, ending the sale of alcoholic drinks and giving birth to what became known as “organized crime.”
RONN MOTT: The Bully
The mess the Miami Dolphins find themselves in is a simple case of bullying. The man who would like to be rather “incognito,” Richie Incognito, is not. The entire world knows about him now and his bullying may have been sanctioned by his Miami Dolphins’ football team.
LIZ CIANCONE: Even mild forecast can give you the shivers
The local weather report the other evening included a bit of folklore. Our weather guru said that the story is that if snakes have not crawled off to winter quarters by late October, we were in for a mild winter.
MARK BENNETT: A degree of success
Determination to get that diploma Larry Bird’s deepest bond with fellow ISU alums, students
RONN MOTT: Obama ‘stubs toe’ — and worse — so far on Affordable Care Act
Abraham Lincoln, after losing the race for the available Senate seat (National Senate), was asked by a reporter how it felt. Mr. Lincoln said, “I feel like a sixteen-year-old boy who has just run across a field and stubbed his toe on a rock. It hurts too much to laugh and I’m too old to cry.” President Obama has run into a similar situation. He certainly has stubbed his toe on the rock of his administration, The Affordable Care Act.
RONN MOTT: ‘My team lost’
My team lost. The team I have been a fan of since 1946 lost the World Series.
I’m surprised they did as well as they did. The St. Louis Cardinals limped into the final seven games of baseball this year with perhaps the best young pitching staff, but everything else fell rather flat. Two power hitters and one was hurt early in the Series, which left only one power hitter … not enough to beat the booming Bosox.
RONN MOTT: ‘It's a job’
I was recently talking to Jim Meece, Republican Parke County commissioner and history teacher at Turkey Run High School. (WAXI 104.9) We talked about many things … one of them being Congress and what they’re supposed to do.
LIZ CIANCONE: Extra hour gives more time to reset all the clocks
At the risk of becoming a bore, I really hate daylight saving time.
MARK BENNETT: Brad Fenton and friends set dominos in motion to make Larry Bird statue a reality
The idea has been out there for awhile, floating.
Locals in the 1980s, ’90s and 2000s would say, “They need to put up a statue of Larry Bird. I mean, one of the all-time greatest basketball players played right here in Terre Haute at Indiana State University.”
RONN MOTT: Thoughts about the ‘Redskins’ controversy
I am not amused by the uproar for the Washington NFL team to stop calling themselves the “Redskins.” I think it is, frankly, much to do about nothing.
- More Opinion Columns Headlines
- RONN MOTT: Seeds from the same tree