subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Tue, Nov 10 2009 

Published: November 15, 2008 09:06 pm    print this story   email this story  

TRIBUNE-STAR EDITORIAL: 2007 Mayoral election challenge disruptive, unnecessary

Community will benefit little from this process

The Tribune-Star

TERRE HAUTE The collective shiver felt down the spines of people in Terre Haute on Thursday was a preview to the uneasy realization that the 2007 mayoral election is still — STILL! — not over.

If ever there was an election from which Terre Haute needed permanent relief, the 2007 election is it. But the stunning ruling last week from a divided Indiana Court of Appeals promises that the results of that hotly contested and intensely competitive political fracas will remain in dispute for the foreseeable future.

To say that this twist in the political/legal process is unfortunate would be an understatement. Terre Haute and its people, as is the case with all Americans and the cities in which they live, are caught in the throes of economic uncertainty. The nation’s financial meltdown and related crises represent a significant drain on any community’s energy. Being forced to revisit and relive a divisive election is not something this community needs.

We understand former Mayor Kevin Burke’s inclination to file suit in an effort to hold current Mayor Duke Bennett accountable for what now appears to have been a violation of the law restricting the political activities of people being paid by federal funds. During the mayoral campaign, Bennett was employed in a management position by Hamilton Center, a Valley-wide provider of mental health and other services funded in part by federal government programs. Burke, with encouragement from his supporters, took the matter to court in hopes of having Bennett’s election nullified. He was well within his rights to do so.

But we do not condone Burke’s actions in this matter. As previously stated here, by waiting until after he lost the election to challenge his opponent’s eligibility to be a candidate, Burke set the community on a course that assured continued divisiveness and prevented it from moving forward in a constructive way.

The Appeals Court decision marked a significant victory for Burke in the legal process, even though it did not declare him the victor. Rather, the decision, if upheld on appeal by higher courts, sets the course for a special election which may or may not include Burke as a candidate.

Bennett has been mayor for almost a year and will remain so in the weeks and months ahead. Much time is bound to lapse before the legal process is complete and a final resolution is delivered. It is possible that any special election in the future would not occur until near the end of Bennett’s term.

There is benefit to maintaining the integrity of the election process and ensuring applicable laws are followed. One must consider, however, that suffering through a mayoral special election could cancel out those benefits. This precedent-setting case may thrill legal scholars, but the people of Terre Haute get nothing more than an unnecessary and expensive disruption in the political process.

We preferred that Burke not pursue this challenge. But the legal course is set. Whatever happens, the community will be forced to quickly adjust. No doubt it will. Future resentment or disenchantment with the process, however, may not so easily be overcome.

print this story   email this story  



Photos


None/ (Click for larger image)

Terre Haute Progress Retail health medical manufacturing education

Terre Haute



autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Tribune Star on Facebook
Terre Haute

Terre Haute News Morning Headlines

Terre Haute ClickLocal

Terre Haute Tribune-Star Newspaper Dial-A-Pro

Terre Haute Tribune-Star Newspaper Live in the Clubs

Terre Haute News on Twitter

Today's Featured Jobs

Building Material delivery
TH Area Co. Look-
ing for Exp. Building
Material delivery
driver. Class A. CDl
Req’d, Fork lift E
...>MORE

Flexographic Press Operators
Immediate opening
for Experienced
Flexographic Press
Operators. Excellent
pay. Apply in person
...>MORE

See all ads

Today's Featured Autos

ford 861 Tractor
Ford 861 Tractor
Plus extras $5000
(812)877-2544 or
(812)240-7762
...>MORE

Wanted Grain Truck
wanted: Grain
truck w/14’ bed. Call
eves. (812)533-2234
...>MORE

See all ads

Today's Featured Homes

E. side location
E. side location,
huge 1 bdrm All util
pd. $550 + Dep.
208-0568, 299-2266
...>MORE

427 N 13th
Bdrm $525mo,
+dep., Utils Inc., 427
N 13th 229-1006

...>MORE

See all ads

Today's Cool Stuff

Wanted Grain truck
wanted: Grain
truck w/14’ bed. Call
eves. (812)533-2234
...>MORE

Bunk bed
Nasser’s Consign-
ment bunk bed
w/bedding $250 2355
3rd Ave 232- 7456
...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index