Most people count the Wabash River as an economic asset for Terre Haute.
It holds rich history, attracts visitors with its scenery and packs vast potential as a wildlife recreation magnet.
The Wabash also serves as the Indiana-Illinois border from Vigo County south, the river’s final 200 miles. That nearness to Illinois is an economic plus, too, at least in the view of Indiana Commerce Secretary Victor Smith. In the competition to attract new employers, businesses can’t help but see greener grass — and profits — in the Hoosier state, Smith contended Tuesday on a visit to Terre Haute.
Of course, economic development officials in the Land of Lincoln beg to differ.
Smith talked up Indiana’s status as the business-friendly, low-tax, lean government “fiscal envy” of other states as keynote speaker of the annual Ground Hog Day Economic Forecast breakfast at Indiana State University. He resolved for Indiana to “be a little bit more aggressive this year in how we go about selling Indiana.” How so? “We are really doing a lot more of a ‘hunter mentality,’ going out and grabbing companies and grabbing industries and bringing them back to Indiana,” he explained.
In an interview after his address, Smith described ways communities such as Terre Haute could gather local public and private sector leaders to craft a “collaboration plan” and enlist the help of the entity he leads — the Indiana Economic Development Corp. — to attract businesses. In the interview, he asked rhetorically, “What are the advantages here in Terre Haute?” A reporter mentioned the local colleges and workforce, and Smith added Indiana’s “attractive environment for business, first” and Interstate 70, which bisects the city.
Then, as Smith described an “inverted wedding cake” model of advantages — including the Midwest’s abundance of manufacturing, logistics and life sciences employers — he said, “This region is a very fertile area for a lot of traditional things, and [benefits from] location, location, location. And I would throw into ‘location’ your proximity to Illinois, which is one of the worst states in the country for doing business and getting worse, literally. So that’s an advantage.”
Asked for specifics, Smith said, “I’ll answer that just with facts.
“Look at the tax policy,” he continued. “Look at the unfunded pension liability that’s looming. There’s only one direction for taxation in Illinois, and that’s up. Their system is broken. That’s not news. Those are facts. Don’t take my word for it, look at third-party rankings.” Smith cited Illinois’ worker’s compensation rate as two times more costly to a business as another example. By contrast, during Tuesday’s focus on the economy, Indiana was lauded for its rankings as No. 1 in the Midwest and top five in America on Chief Executive Magazine’s best places to do business.
An Illinois economic development official sees the situation differently.
One of the worst states for business and getting worse? That “would be a surprise to all the new companies that are looking to locate in our state,” said Dave Roeder, communications director for the Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity.
Obviously, Illinois’ post-Blagojevich, post-recession troubles are well-documented. Roeder acknowledged the 8.6-percent unemployment rate (third-highest in the U.S.), saying, “We’re trying to get that unemployment rate down as fast as we can. We’ve got a long ways to go.” (It should be noted that Indiana’s jobless rate, now 6.9 percent, is 21st-highest, and while improving, it has stayed above the national rate for much of the past few years.) Illinois’ rock-bottom credit rating also remains a massive burden, but the state got good marks from Moody’s Investors Service for pension reforms approved in December, aimed at reducing its pension liabilities by $160 billion during the next 30 years.
Despite Illinois’ problems, several third-party rankings cast a promising picture of the state’s future.
Roeder referred to Site Selection Magazine’s 2013 top states for business climate list. It rated Illinois fifth nationally in the number of new and expanded corporate facilities. In its overall list, the magazine put Indiana at No. 10 and Illinois just a few notches back at No. 19. Also, the Anderson Economic Group’s 2013 state business tax burden rankings — based on U.S. Census figures — put Illinois at No. 20 and Indiana at No. 28. And, the CareerBuilder and Economic Modeling Specialists list of the best states for new business establishments — based on U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages — placed Illinois third (behind only Texas and New York), with Indiana rated 24th.
Lists abound and vary, as do states’ economic-development tactics.
“It’s a very competitive market,” Roeder said, “and all states have their different forms of incentives to try to win businesses from somewhere else.”
The idea of Indiana “hunting” in Illinois isn’t a surprise.
“If I were Indiana and I were looking to grab some new business, I would be looking at Illinois, too,” Roeder said, “because our economy is so much larger than theirs, and we have so many more Fortune 500 companies here.”
The primary ways states become business magnets, Roeder said, are by growing an innovative economy, offering a good quality of life in communities, maintaining transportation and investing in a qualified workforce. Given that, Roeder said, “We just feel we’ve got a lot to offer before you even discuss the issue of taxes or incentives.”
Tuesday morning, Smith emphasized the importance of developing the “quality of place” in Indiana communities, and highlighted a current legislative proposal (House Bill 1035) that would require the Indiana Economic Development Corp. to assess needs and potential of Hoosier cities. Smith suggested the idea could lead to a $1 billion fund for communities to enhance their “quality of place” and infrastructure. At this point, though, it’s only a proposal to conduct a study.
It deserves to be more than that. When it comes to Indiana’s economic-development advantages, quality of life should be at the top of the list.
Mark Bennett can be reached at 812-231-4377 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Most people count the Wabash River as an economic asset for Terre Haute.
- News Columns
MIKE LUNSFORD: Lake Michigan’s ‘Wonderful World of Color’
Despite the beauty around us, Joanie and I thought of television as we sat on a gorgeous Michigan beach one evening last week.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Expiring term heightens the urgency of one lawmaker’s push for reform
State Rep. Rebecca Kubacki had plans for her return to the General Assembly next January.
The two-term Republican from Kosciusko County wanted to exert “full force” to roll back a law that prevents the children of undocumented immigrants from paying in-state tuition to attend state colleges and universities.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Road to funding Indiana highways jammed
If you’ve driven on either of Indiana’s two busiest interstates recently, you’ll understand why a blue-ribbon commission last week called for adding traffic lanes to those harrowing highways.
MARK BENNETT: Making road work a barrel of fun for drivers
We’re lucky orange barrels can’t talk.
MIKE LUNSFORD: Wet in Wyoming, wandering turtles and other tales of the road
It is an odd thing, after all the miles I drove a few weeks ago — to the mountains of Wyoming and back again — that today I remember most of all stopping along the road in two places nearly 600 miles apart.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Financial hardships mount for military families
Days before the July 4th holiday, Holly Petraeus stood on the steps of the imposing Indiana War Memorial, in front of a bank of cameras, and made a plea to military families: Don’t let pride stand in the way of asking for help.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Tangled road to simplified tax code
Pushing his idea that a simpler tax system can boost Indiana’s economy, Gov. Mike Pence invited prominent conservative economists to a closed-to-the-public conference last week.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Homegrown spirits return to State Fair
Mark Webb is counting on patrons of the Indiana State Fair to be better behaved this summer than they were in 1946, when a celebratory post-war crowd almost trashed the place.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Coauthor of election laws may have to worry about own race
Connie Lawson had a speech ready for the state Republican party delegates who picked her as their Secretary of State candidate, putting her at the top of an all-female ticket in November.
MAX JONES: Fathers, sons and the tides of war
The wonderful and poignant stories and tributes the past week about D-Day have been both heartbreaking and uplifting.
MARK BENNETT: Terre Haute: The downtown that can
Two words can refute many of the “can’ts” occasionally uttered about this town.
MIKE LUNSFORD: It’s the true ‘face of spring’
I’d be a liar if I said that I miss the yellow carpet of dandelions that dotted my front yard just a few weeks ago.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Gregg weighs another shot at gov’s office
John Gregg made his handlebar mustache an iconic image in his failed 2012 race for governor, turning it into a campaign logo and telling tales of how he stuck to his Yosemite Sam guns when advisers pressed him to shave it.
MARK BENNETT: Returning the dome to Normal
Folks at Indiana State University haven’t summoned Indiana Jones, yet.
MARK BENNETT: Midwest baseball fans flock to Valley tourney
As a major sporting event — the Missouri Valley Conference Baseball Championship — began to unfold in Terre Haute this week, a familiar question cropped up.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Summer study groups do the Legislature’s legwork
Back before the recession of 2008 hit Indiana, Gov. Mitch Daniels launched an ambitious initiative called Hoosiers on the Move.
MIKE LUNSFORD: A face only a mother could love
It is fitting that Mother’s Day comes when it does, for spring is a maternal season, one for new beginnings, for birth and rebirth, for flowering and nurturing and caring.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Struggling schools look for funding relief
Ball State University economist Michael Hicks had some unwelcome news when he met with leaders of the scenic Ohio River town of Madison last summer, after they asked his advice on growing their community.
ALICIA MORGAN: Today, let’s celebrate the rewards
Mother’s Day is not about mothers at all.
B.J. RILEY: Tooth Fairy’s real; I’ve seen her
As strange as it might sound, I think of the tooth fairy each Mother’s Day.
MARK BENNETT: Like other Indiana counties, Vigo struggles with voter apathy
Vigo Countians who trekked to the new voting centers, who endured long lines at a couple of popular sites, and who learned to use the new touch-screen machines displayed solid civic spirit in Tuesday’s primary election.
MAUREEN HAYDEN: Public higher education graduation rates leave much to be desired
On the sprawling urban campus of Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, Zebulun Davenport has one of the more difficult jobs.
MARK BENNETT: Low, and OK with it
The little sticker in the upper-left corner of a vehicle’s windshield reminds us — three months in advance — when to get an oil change.
A safe, scenic path from downtown Terre Haute to the river worth planning
The community has to want it.
MIKE LUNSFORD: Lasting beauty: Miss Kinsey’s forsythia
It always seems like it’s Sunday when we notice Miss Kinsey’s forsythia. Joanie and I will be driving home from church, most often with our windows down so we can enjoy springtime breezes and smells.
MAUREEN HAYDEN: Governor beyond the office, script
On a shelf in the home office of Gov. Mike Pence are some cowboy spurs and an old pair of riding boots — signs of how the first-term executive and his family relax in their spare time.
MARK BENNETT: The memories from a baseball mitt fit like a glove
Man hasn’t developed the technology for time travel.
The smell of your old baseball glove can come pretty close, though.
Answering the call
Static was the only thing on TV or radio. People were on their knees as they prayed. It was, as if for three whole days, the world stood still.
MIKE LUNSFORD: One man’s trash is, well, another man’s trash
Many people are growing weary of ecological doomsdayers, and if so, they are the folks most likely to tell us that Planet Earth isn’t in that bad of a shape, that it can repair itself, that new technologies just around the corner will solve our carbon emissions and greenhouse gases and oil consumption and the ever-growing pile of plastic in which we are drowning.
MAUREEN HAYDEN: Want better teacher ratings? Ask the kids
The state may be back where it started, encumbered with a flawed teacher grading system, a year after implementing what were meant to be tough new standards.
- More News Columns Headlines
- MIKE LUNSFORD: Lake Michigan’s ‘Wonderful World of Color’