TERRE HAUTE —
The developer of Cobblestone Crossings has filed a lawsuit against the Vigo County Area Plan Commission.
The company, Southern Indiana Investments Co. Three LLC, claims an action from the Area Plan Commission on Wednesday that would require that a wall be in front of Viscaya subdivision is not a zoning requirement for the last phase of the development of Cobblestone Crossings. The company also says the commission’s action was “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion and not in accordance with Indiana law,” according to the lawsuit filed Friday in Vigo County Superior Court 1.
The lawsuit contends Southern Indiana Investments complied with the county’s zoning requirements and its subdivision control ordinance.
Thomas Bedsole, attorney for the Indianapolis law firm Frost Brown Todd representing the investment company, said Monday the company installed a wall along Woodgate as part of an agreement with the county.
“The wall was for the prior phase,” Bedsole said. “It described the commitment for that phase but also described the wall as extending all the way down the eastern boundary of the property into the new phase. The plat shows that for phase 4, and does show the wall consistent with the commitment.
“What the neighbors are requesting is a whole new wall along the southern boundary. Technically, the time to put in a wall was when the original PUD (Planned Unit Development) was approved, which was back in 2007,” he said.
Bedsole said the investment company agreed to a wall along Woodgate; however, that agreement did not extend beyond what has already been walled. “There is no agreement, and we don’t have to agree to it because it is not in the PUD,” he said.
John Hanley, vice president of the Area Plan Commission, said “our feeling as a Plan Commission is we have the authority to attach a commitment to any replatting and that is what we chose to do for the second phase. They have the opportunity to either accept it or sue to determine that we don’t, but we believe we do.”
Hanley said an agreement for the third phase called for a wall built along the north and east perimeters, but also states for a future phase to the south. “Their interpretation is because we didn’t draw the pencil line along Viscaya, but drew along Woodgate South, that is what they meant.
“The intention was to provide a physical barrier and a visual screening buffer for the residential houses that abut the property of this multi-family development,” Hanley said. “It is our feeling that we certainly have the authority to ask that they put that in there, and they are questioning that authority. If the courts rule that we don’t have that [authority], they win.”
Bedsole said the PUD was approved to establish different districts and zoning requirements. Zoning requirements in the last section to be developed was established as R2M, allowing for two-story apartments. “Once it has been agreed upon, it is established. So as you are going further and further down the development process, the discretion becomes less and less, so that at the very last approval, and this is the last approval, if we meet the R2M requirements, they don’t have the discretion to deny it,” Bedsole said.
“The idea being: If that discretion was there, you would constantly be litigating it over and over again every time you came in for an approval,” Bedsole said. “This is the final, final approval. It has been approved by the county commissioners, so to now go in and deny it is an abuse of discretion.”
“Their argument, in my opinion, if all you have to do is check off the boxes and meet what is in the ordinances, if that’s all that is ever required, then we don’t need to exist as a Plan Commission. Might as well have three people reviewing that the check marks are in the right place and it is what it is,” Hanley said.
“I don’t think you appoint 14 people to sit on a commission if all they are asked to do is review and make sure all the check marks are checked,” Hanley said. “We are simply trying to get this right. It is the final phase of the final build out,” he said.
Hanley said each time a PUD is presented “is a whole new deal, with the ability to change and alter. That is for their luxury to be able to change and alter, which is what they have done. They originally planned on single-family homes and condos there, and now it is multi-family development. So the original agreement does not have anything to do with replatting; that is why they have to come back,” Hanley said.
Stacy Gough, a real estate professional who also is resident of Viscaya Point subdivision, said she thinks the agreement made along Woodgate “states a future phase and we are that future phase, that the wall be extended behind Viscaya Point, and we are hoping the judge sees that.”
Gough said Viscaya Point residents hired Attorney James McDonald to represent them, and he appeared at Wednesday’s Area Plan Commission meeting.
Gough said residents could challenge a ruling that does not include an extension of the wall. “We think [the wall] is on those plans, which is stamped and certified,” Gough said.
Reporter Howard Greninger can be reached at 812-231-4204 or howard. email@example.com.
Claim: Commission action on wall exceeded zoning requirements for new phase
TERRE HAUTE —
The developer of Cobblestone Crossings has filed a lawsuit against the Vigo County Area Plan Commission.
Historic Ohio Boulevard house inspired by 1948 Cary Grant movie
Spurred in 1948 by a newly released movie staring Cary Grant and Myrna Loy, coupled with a growing post-World War II housing market, General Electric partnered with Hollywood’s RKO Studios to build “dream homes” throughout the country.
A panel of public and private officials is calling for $10 billion in projects to upgrade Indiana’s aging roads and bridges, but its members concede there’s no money to pay for it all.
MARK BENNETT: Making road work a barrel of fun for drivers
We’re lucky orange barrels can’t talk.
City Council to take up city finances tonight
The Terre Haute City Council will have a chance in a special meeting tonight to delve deeply into the city’s financial health. However, council members are being asked to avoid raising the most controversial subject of recent weeks: The city’s use of Redevelopment Commission tax increment finance (TIF) money.
Bennett accepts $5,000 fine in ethics settlement
Former Indiana Schools Superintendent Tony Bennett has agreed to pay $5,000 as part of a settlement with Indiana’s ethics watchdog in which he admits to using state resources for campaign work but is cleared of formal ethics violations in the grade-change scandal that cost him his job as Florida’s schools chief last year.
Vermillion Jail trusties face new charges
Two former inmate trusties at the Vermillion County Jail face new criminal charges after a recently discovered security breach at the jail.
Lawrence police acquire armored military vehicle
A central Indiana city has acquired an armored military vehicle for use in highly dangerous situations.
Free carwash for law enforcement
Mike’s Carwash locations in Central Indiana, including Terre Haute, will honor the sacrifice of IMPD Officer Perry Renn and thank all those who serve and protect our communities with a free carwash for police and emergency personnel today and Friday.
Hitting a high note
A 17-year-old from Casey, Ill., won “The Voice of the Valley” Tuesday night, singing and shaking his hips and legs to an Elvis Presley song, then wooing the grandstand audience at the Wabash Valley Fairgrounds with a country tune.
Clay County residents clean up debris, get power back
Several power outages still affected hundreds of Duke Energy customers on Tuesday, more than 24 hours after storms and strong winds swept through west-central Indiana, leaving a swath of damage in the Staunton, Brazil and Center Point areas.
Return to Indiana?
Evan Bayh is keeping Indiana Democrats on hold.
Planning under way for 2014 Downtown Block Party
Wabash Avenue will be full of activity Aug. 23 as the 2014 Downtown Terre Haute Block Party takes over five city blocks in a celebration of music, food and events.
VIDEO UPDATE: Guys give food bank a lift
A $14,000 donation Tuesday from Guys Who Give enables Catholic Charities to be at nearly 75 percent of its $2.5 million goal to purchase and operate a new, larger food bank near Terre Haute International Airport-Hulman Field.
‘Dangerous’ suspect in police custody
A man sought by the Vermillion County Sheriff's Department has been nabbed by police in Indianapolis.
eBus brings financial empowerment to town
A 40-foot long mobile classroom is scheduled to roll into Terre Haute today, carrying what its sponsors call “financial empowerment.”
Maker of history
A humble man with a heart for helping others is an apt description for Terre Haute resident Curtis B. Culver.
Culver died July 2 at age 94, leaving behind a legacy of missionary work and social involvement.
Petitioners push for recycling at fair
A Vigo County environmental activist hopes to convince the Vigo County Fair Board to start recycling, especially during the county fair, and has started an online petition.
Veterans call on commissioners to protect war memorial
Installing a camera on the second floor of the Sullivan County Courthouse may be one solution to curtailing what several veterans are calling a disgrace to a memorial that honors Americans who gave their lives in service to the country.
Schools ethics case: Proposed deal to be reviewed
The State Ethics Commission is set to review a proposed settlement Thursday in the ethics case against former Indiana Schools Superintendent Tony Bennett.
Man airlifted to Indy after early morning crash
A Clay City man sustained non-life-threatening injuries in a head-on collision early Monday morning on Indiana 46 at Riley Road southeast of Terre Haute.
Man agrees to plea on youth sex charges
A Terre Haute man received a suspended sentence in a plea agreement signed Monday as his jury trial was about to commence in Vigo Superior Court 1.
Downtown fire victim ID released
Carbon monoxide poisoning was the cause of death for 61-year-old William Sonnefield, a resident of Deming Center who died in a late Thursday night fire inside his apartment. The Vigo County Coroner’s office released the victim’s name Monday.
Susan Ooley-Viray’s love of tractors started as a Christmas gift about five years ago from her husband, John.
St. George's: Century of faith
From its formation in a sewing circle of European immigrant women, surviving a fire that destroyed its building, to expanding with a new parish hall, St. George’s Episcopal Church has endured to celebrate its 100th anniversary next Sunday.
MIKE LUNSFORD: Wet in Wyoming, wandering turtles and other tales of the road
It is an odd thing, after all the miles I drove a few weeks ago — to the mountains of Wyoming and back again — that today I remember most of all stopping along the road in two places nearly 600 miles apart.
STATE OF THE STATEHOUSE: Financial hardships mount for military families
Days before the July 4th holiday, Holly Petraeus stood on the steps of the imposing Indiana War Memorial, in front of a bank of cameras, and made a plea to military families: Don’t let pride stand in the way of asking for help.
RESTAURANT INSPECTIONS: July 7, 2014
Man in critical condition after July 4 stabbing
A Sullivan County man remained in critical condition Sunday at Methodist Hospital in Indianapolis after being stabbed on July 4.
Day at the fair
Though the Vigo County Fair officially opens today, Saturday was a busy day around the Wabash Valley Fairgrounds as open class exhibits were entered and judged and commercial vendors made final adjustments to their stands.
Finding a meth lab
Finding out if a property has been the previous site of a clandestine methamphetamine lab has become easier through a new online database recently rolled out by the Indiana State Police.
- More News Headlines
- Historic Ohio Boulevard house inspired by 1948 Cary Grant movie