TERRE HAUTE —
Rules bug people. Can’t live with ’em, can’t live without ’em.
A bill brewing in the Indiana House of Representatives profoundly tests two pretty clear rules.
House Bill 1003 would give families tax-supported scholarships — commonly known as vouchers — to send their child to a private school. The vouchers would cover up to 90 percent of a private-school tuition, which averages about $5,500 annually in Indiana (on the high school level). Many private schools are affiliated with religious institutions.
Such a law holds many ramifications, especially the diversion of limited state funds for public schools to private institutions. Another consequence of HB 1003, small as it seems, is the potential for private high schools to use taxpayer-funded vouchers as an incentive to recruit high-caliber athletes.
Two rules, in place for a long time in the Hoosier State, pertain to the bill’s basic premise and its fallout.
According to the Indiana Constitution, “No money shall be drawn from the state treasury for the benefit of any religious or theological institution.” It’s hard to imagine the spirit of that clause condones the use of taxpayer money to pay a private school’s costs for educating a child.
If the bill becomes law, it also would render Rule 20-1 of the Indiana High School Athletic Association bylaws far more difficult to enforce. That rule reads: “The recruitment or attempted recruitment of a prospective student, through the use of undue influence, is prohibited. ‘Undue influence’ is the act of encouraging or inducing a prospective student to attend a school for athletic purposes.”
The latter situation obviously pales in comparison to the larger concern about siphoning funds intended for the state’s public school system into facilities that operate under private policies and, uh, rules.
Still, the question of whether vouchers will become state-funded athletic scholarships exemplifies the unknowns surrounding HB 1003.
The bottom line is, private schools don’t have to accept all students, unlike public schools, which are required to do so by the Indiana Constitution. (There’s that rule thing again.) The “common (or public) schools” are part of a “general and uniform system,” the state constitution continues, that is “without charge and equally open to all.”
“If they’re going to allow private schools to accept these vouchers, [private schools] need to accept all children, rather than just the ones they want,” Indiana PTA President Tina Hartman said by telephone from Fort Wayne. Her point is valid; the tax subsidization of vouchers essentially moves participating private schools into the “general and uniform system.”
While the bill contains provisions related to the acceptance standards of private schools that use the state vouchers, it would not compel them to take all students, said state Rep. Robert Behning, the Indianapolis Republican who authored the bill. Unless the state is willing to fund such private schools at the same overall level of a public school, they can’t, in fairness, be expected to “throw their doors open and just let everyone in,” Behning said by telephone last week.
When asked whether HB 1003 also would invite athletic recruiting by private high schools, Behning said, “no more than our traditional public schools do.”
Of course, anyone who’s spent serious time around prep sports knows IHSAA Rule 20-1 has been violated over the decades. Still, it is a rule, and the IHSAA expects its 410 member schools — of which 50 are private — to abide by it or face investigations and penalties.
The introduction of state-paid vouchers for private schools adds a huge twist to the situation, but doesn’t change the association’s expectations.
“Offering a voucher to parents for the use of meeting tuition requirements at private schools may carry the potential for abuse,” IHSAA Commissioner Bobby Cox said in a statement to the Tribune-Star. “I remain confident that the educational leaders at our member schools will continue to uphold the bylaws agreed upon by the association and stand ready to assist Indiana families in reaching informed decisions on the education of their children.”
Folks who fear rampant recruiting wars may hinge their hopes on HB 1003 failing to pass through the current session of the General Assembly. But, as Behning accurately stated, “I believe it will pass the House. I know the governor is very supportive. And the Senate is very supportive as well.” That just about covers that possibility, though Behning made no prediction.
Behning is confident such a law would survive legal challenges, too, though he “expects somebody will take this to court.” Some legal analysts question Behning’s optimism, because the wording of Indiana’s Constitution spells out the separation of church and state more strongly than the U.S. Constitution. But attorneys working for advocates of charter schools and voucher programs think the proposed Indiana law is constitutional, both on a state and federal level. For example, the word “benefit” in the state constitution could become decisive; if state dollars are used for a particular purpose (such as tuition), rather than to just “benefit” a private school, the vouchers could be deemed legal, according to an Indianapolis Star report.
If so, is the IHSAA headed for a wave of recruiting violations and accusations? Well, it depends on what the meaning of the word “is” is. Or is it the meaning of the word “benefit”?
Mark Bennett can be reached at (812) 231-4377 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
TERRE HAUTE —
Rules bug people. Can’t live with ’em, can’t live without ’em.
- Mark Bennett Opinion
MARK BENNETT: New public-access point begins quest to create more spots to experience river
Fairness holds no power over the Wabash River.
MARK BENNETT: People spaces
Demolition machinery chipped away at the buildings on the 500 block of Wabash Avenue. I stood and watched awhile, last week. By July 2015, a new $18.7-million structure will replace those relics.
MARK BENNETT: Blessings of a long, cold, snowy winter
As spring, summer arrive, Hoosiers will appreciate icy months (well, maybe a little)
MARK BENNETT: Healing Indiana’s Achilles’ heel
Illinois served as the easy target.
At that moment.
MARK BENNETT: Yeah, yeah, yeah... For some grownups, first impression not so fab
We’re pretty smart here in middle America.
Our DNA carries the common-sense chromosome. From birth, Midwestern culture begins honing us into the most rational and perceptive of human beings. Sure, our prisons are full, but generally, we mean well. And we’re wise.
MARK BENNETT: Remembering the less glitzy days on Manning’s road to the Super Bowl
A blur of memories.
They’ll flicker fast and furious tonight, like a spinning Rolodex, when Peyton Manning runs onto the MetLife Stadium turf in Jersey City, as a Denver Bronco, playing for a Super Bowl ring against the Seattle Seahawks. Most Hauteans will experience flashbacks, too.
MARK BENNETT: A lengthening climb
The American economy is improving.
Confidence has risen since the government shutdown by the polarized Congress last fall. Indicators in various sectors show promise.
MARK BENNETT: Tackling entrenched economic problems could brighten local forecast
Without a DeLorean, there’s no going back to 1995.
MARK BENNETT: What is Indiana’s image in the eyes of the world?
A bus pulled up to the curb near the riverfront in downtown Chicago. An unusual advertisement was painted on its side.
Raising the bar
Around coffeeshops, kitchen tables and office watercoolers, Hoosiers have cussed and discussed the federal health care law.
MARK BENNETT: ABA’s record proves Bobby Leonard’s a legit Hall of Famer
Bobby Leonard symbolized the feisty competitive flair of the old ABA.
MARK BENNETT: Letter from coach’s young daughter put pro sports, Christmas in perspective
Most of us sympathize with people forced to work on Thanksgiving and Christmas.
That list is growing, now that Black Friday has morphed into Black Thursday, causing retail employees to join doctors, nurses, hospital staffers, police, firefighters, emergency responders, military members, convenience store clerks, road crews and media to spend holidays at work. Ideally, we’ll feel gratitude when we require their services on those special days. Too often, their sacrificed time gets taken for granted.
Terry Leonard wanted the executives to remember her dad, and their family, at Christmastime.
And, amazingly, they listened.
MARK BENNETT: A degree of success
Determination to get that diploma Larry Bird’s deepest bond with fellow ISU alums, students
MARK BENNETT: Brad Fenton and friends set dominos in motion to make Larry Bird statue a reality
The idea has been out there for awhile, floating.
Locals in the 1980s, ’90s and 2000s would say, “They need to put up a statue of Larry Bird. I mean, one of the all-time greatest basketball players played right here in Terre Haute at Indiana State University.”
MARK BENNETT: Next chapter set to begin
Use the classic Tommy Tutone song to memorize the following number …
MARK BENNETT: One-ring blues?
Minutes before kickoff tonight, the Lucas Oil Stadium tech crew should play Sam Cooke’s classic, “(What a) Wonderful World” over the sound system.
MARK BENNETT: At Peace in Parke County
Northwestern Parke County — The stream merely trickles beneath Mill Creek Bridge. It’s just a few inches deep, but the water keeps moving.
MARK BENNETT: Terre Haute native Tommy John belongs in Cooperstown for pitching like a Hall of Famer
Few players in history left a greater impact on baseball than Tommy John.
And he did so through his performance on the field.
MARK BENNETT: Remotely confused
“Must See TV,” where have you gone?
MARK BENNETT: Popularity Contest: Congress does little to improve its standing with Americans
The members of Congress ardently resisting the Affordable Care Act emphasize its unpopularity.
MARK BENNETT: ‘The voice of the Democratic Party’
The ad stands as a campaign classic. Its scenario is part of history. Its narrator would be familiar to millions of Americans, yet anonymous, too.
MARK BENNETT: Transparency in public decision-making includes sincerely listening to the people
Transparency isn’t universally accepted in public entities.
MARK BENNETT: This Little Light: Remote chapel keeps a light shining on story of Flight 93
Father Al explained the meaning of the lamp. He asked me to light it.
The reverence in his voice offset the raspiness, left by his latest battle with cancer. Clearly, he saw this place as special.
MARK BENNETT: Reflections on the Wabash
The series “500 Miles of Wabash” wrapped up last Sunday after a five-week run. Readers offered some enlightening insights, memories and photographs as the series unfolded.
MARK BENNETT: Current Information: Put your Wabash knowledge to the test … or quiz
Just for fun, ponder a few questions concerning the large waterway flowing through Indiana and Terre Haute, as the Tribune-Star’s series, “500 Miles of Wabash” concludes in today’s editions. Those who’ve followed the five-part series of stories, photographs and videos about people and communities uniquely embracing the Wabash River may have a head start. If you’re just catching up, check them out in the online editions at www.tribstar.com.
- Answers to the Wabash River Quiz
MARK BENNETT: Pedestrian paths across the Wabash few, so far, but appreciated
The future tends to sneak up on you. Planning for it offers no guarantees, but it helps.
MARK BENNETT: Questions of fairness, impartiality, public trust legitimate in wake of school rating controversy
The discovery of a double-standard in public policy — or the appearance of it — weakens trust. The acceptance of a double-standard in public policy — or the appearance of it — erases trust. Indiana needs to draw a clear line between the former and the latter, and not cross it.
MARK BENNETT: Living downstream: From source, Wabash bears mark of mankind mile after mile
Something was missing. I’d never visited this spot before, but the view looked familiar. I’ve walked the banks of the Wabash River and its tributaries countless times, catching crawdads and skipping rocks in Honey Creek as a kid. On the other side of the state, where the Wabash crosses from Ohio into Indiana, trees arched over the water as it ran under a bridge on a quiet country road. It looked like western Indiana, except for one absent element. Litter.
MARK BENNETT: We are Hauteans (ho-shuns)
I fielded an hilariously disturbing question recently. A friend asked if the word “Hautean” is meant to be a derogatory label.
- More Mark Bennett Opinion Headlines
- MARK BENNETT: New public-access point begins quest to create more spots to experience river