TERRE HAUTE —
Reliving the 1980s may sound tempting.
Ah, simpler times. Then again … hair styles as big as mushroom clouds, “Miami Vice” jackets, the trickle-down theory, New Coke, Yugos.
OK, “Back to the Future”-style nostalgia obviously has its limits. After all, most people would hope their incomes, adjusted for inflation, have changed — for the better — since the days of “Where’s the beef?” and “Whip It.”
But, alas, the paychecks of thousands of Hoosiers and Hauteans should carry a Memory Lane address.
The average Vigo Countian enjoys a standard of living equal to that which the rest of the nation experienced, on average, in 1986.
1986. Chernobyl happened that year, and Geraldo Rivera opened Al Capone’s worthless vault.
Twenty-seven years later, a new study by Ball State University’s Center for Business and Economic Research analyzes per-capita incomes of Indiana residents in 2010. The researchers adjusted those numbers for inflation and assigned each county a year in which that county’s present standard of living corresponds to the average standard of living nationally. In most places, Hoosiers’ income levels stand a couple decades behind Americans elsewhere. The state’s average 2010 income of $34,042 matched the national level of 1996, according to BSU’s report, “The Causes of State Differences in Per Capita Income: How Does Indiana Fare?”
Vigo County, with a $30,612 average per-capita income rate, lingers a decade behind even most Hoosiers. So does Vigo’s neighboring counties of Parke (1982), Sullivan (1983), Clay (1984) and Greene (1986). Vermillion lives in comparatively robust 1994.
As the study’s lead researcher, Michael Hicks, explained the numbers by telephone from Muncie, he quipped, “I’m calling you from 1984.”
Muncie and Ball State lie within Delaware County, where average incomes are an ’84-ish $29,565.
Hicks, director of the research center and economics professor at BSU, emphasized that the income figures include caveats. The numbers are skewed a bit in counties with large Amish populations, big farms (where incomes may not reflect wealth) or thousands of low-earning college students. Still, those variables only slightly move the needle. LaGrange County in northeast Indiana, for example, is home to lots of self-sufficient Amish folks, the state’s lowest per-capita income at $19,938 and a standard of living last seen nationally in 1964.
“For LaGrange County, [the Amish variable] probably moved them from 1972 to 1964,” Hicks said.
That year, 1964, is significant. It marks the last time incomes in Indiana equaled the rest of America. Since then, the standard of living in Indiana has solidly improved (today, it’s twice that of 1960s families), yet the gap between Hoosiers and residents of other states has widened. Indiana ranked 40th in per-capita income in 2010, 30th in 1980, and 21st in 1950.
The routine response to low wages in this community and state is, “Well, the cost of living is much lower here. It all evens out.”
Housing and many commodities do indeed cost less, Hicks said, but those don’t necessarily translate into a higher standard of living. After an Indiana Chamber of Commerce official, interviewed on NPR’s State Impact Indiana, dismissed the low-income issue raised by the Ball State study because of a low cost of living in the state, Hicks countered in a response to the Tribune-Star. Hicks used Muncie’s situation as an example.
“Muncie is routinely labeled as one of the most affordable housing markets in the country,” Hicks stated. “Given the Chamber’s enthusiasm at that ranking, you’d suppose there’d be a rush to move here. There is not; the housing prices are low for the simple reason that the market for real estate in Delaware County leads to low prices. That is directly linked to the desirability of the community.”
Indiana saw more of its population move out (15.2 percent) than move in (14.7 percent) between 2004 and 2010, according to the study. A reversal of the trend requires patient determination to improve the quality of life in places such as Terre Haute, Muncie and Kokomo, Hicks said. Public policy initiatives help, but they take years to yield results.
Instead of hinging hopes for economic development on landing a huge factory with thousands of jobs, communities can see reliable dividends from investing resources in local schools, parks, trails and early childhood education programs, Hicks said. Improvement in the homegrown portion of Indiana’s labor force must begin in the preschool and K-12 levels. Retaining Hoosier college grads, and luring those from other states, means Indiana, Terre Haute and other communities must invest in quality-of-life amenities. Increasing the number of residents with high-demand skills will draw employers and raise incomes.
Terre Haute has room for improvement. The Ball State report assigned A-to-F grades to various categories for each county. Vigo’s report card: human capital education (C-minus), human capital health (C-minus), government impact and economy (D) and arts-entertainment-recreation (A).
“If you wish to be a prosperous community in the future, you’re going to have to be a community that attracts prosperous people,” Hicks said. “And I’m not talking about a yuppification.”
Yuppies are so 1980s, anyway.
Mark Bennett can be reached at 812-231-4377 or email@example.com.
TERRE HAUTE —
Reliving the 1980s may sound tempting.
- Local & Bistate
Family escapes early morning fire
A Terre Haute family escaped a house fire that destroyed their residence on North Ninth Street early today.
Vigo County Jail Log: Dec. 12, 2013
The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, based on jail records.
Cold snap has Indiana residents bundling up
SOUTH BEND, Ind. (AP) — People across Indiana are bundling up against colder temperatures than parts of the state saw in either of the past two winters.
Gather ’round the tree
As snow fell Wednesday night, chestnuts roasted on a open fire and holiday music filled the air outside one Terre Haute school.
Oil drilling at ISU to start next week
Oil drilling is about to begin on Indiana State University property.
MARK BENNETT: Inspiration will continue to flow through Valley
The Wabash River deserves a spot on lists of New Year’s resolutions.
ISU again looking at reduced state funding
Indiana State University is preparing for nearly $1.4 million in funding cuts, as the state responds to an unexpected drop in tax collections for the first five months of the fiscal year.
Driver survives wild crash
A Terre Haute man is facing drunk driving allegations after a dramatic crash about 4 a.m. Wednesday in southern Vigo County.
Honoring his word
John Etling of Catholic Charities Terre Haute agreed to have his hair dyed orange if the Visiting Nurses Association and Hospice of the Wabash Valley raised $5,000 on Orange Friday.
Hearing postponed for ex-doctor in Omaha killings
A preliminary hearing on an attempted burglary charge has been pushed back for a former doctor accused of killing four people with ties to an Omaha medical school that fired him in 2001.
Pre-sentence report ordered for Archer
A pre-sentence report has been ordered for a man accused of killing his wife and dumping her body in an Ohio ditch.
Ross found guilty of battery
A Terre Haute man was acquitted of involuntary manslaughter but convicted of battering a man who later died at the Vigo County Jail.
South dance clinic set for Saturday
“Dancing Around the Christmas Tree” is the theme of Terre Haute South Vigo High School’s Dance Team Clinic set for Saturday in the school’s auxiliary gym.
Plea submitted for man accused of killing brother
A plea agreement has been submitted for a Terre Haute man accused of killing his brother in 2012.
Thieves stealing copper wire from Interstate light posts
Two state agencies have combined efforts to combat highway lighting wire theft.
Jury returns split verdict in Ross assault case
A Vigo County jury has found James Madison Ross IV not guilty of involuntary manslaughter but guilty of battery resulting in serious bodily injury.
Car rolls several times in a.m. crash, drunk driving suspected
A Terre Haute man is facing drunk driving allegations after a dramatic crash about 4 a.m. today in southern Vigo County.
Equipment to arrive Dec. 14 for oil drilling at Indiana State
After nearly two years of planning and surveying, oil drilling is about to begin on Indiana State University property.
Year nearing its end: 12-month celebration of Wabash spanned Valley
Throughout this year, events and activities have focused attention on the Wabash River through Terre Haute, Vigo County and surrounding counties. It’s been called 2013 Year of the River. On Tuesday, Art Spaces Inc. and Arts Illiana presented a wrapup of the observance’s events.
Cultural planning: Consultant to help city reach arts district designation
Terre Haute officials want a portion of the downtown to be designated by the Indiana Arts Commission as one of the state’s cultural arts districts.
Sheriff: School officers have been a win-win
Placing armed officers in all Vigo County schools not only protects children and staff from violent acts, it also has helped prevent negative behaviors in the schools — both on the part of students and adults.
Gov. Pence details 2014 education agenda
Now that reform has been implemented, Gov. Mike Pence said Tuesday it’s time for Indiana’s legislature to focus on education innovation
Terre Haute man sentenced to Federal Prison
A Terre Haute man has been sentenced to 11 years, three months in federal prison on charges of possession of child pornography.
Closing arguments today in Ross assault trial
Testimony began and concluded Tuesday in the trial of a Terre Haute man accused of battering a person who later died at the Vigo County Jail.
Victim of Monday Parke crash ID’d
Police have identified the victim in a fatal car accident in Parke County on Monday. Linda Chaney, 75, of Reelsville was driving south on Indiana 59 south of Mansfield when her vehicle left the road and struck a tree. She was pronounced dead at the scene.
State Police arrest impaired truck driver
An Illinois semi-trailer driver has been arrested on suspicion of drunken driving after registering more than three times the legal limit on a blood-alcohol test.
ISP arrest impaired semi driver in Putnam County
An Illinois semitrailer driver has been arrested on suspicion of drunken driving after registering more than three times the legal limit on a blood-alcohol test.
Trial begins in manslaughter case
Testimony began today in the trial of a Terre Haute man accused of battering a person who later died at the Vigo County Jail.
Driver ID’d in Monday’s fatal car crash in Parke County
Police have identified the victim in Monday’s fatal car accident in Parke County.
The driver, Linda Chaney, 75, of Reelsville, was driving south on Indiana 59 south of Mansfield when her vehicle left the road and struck a tree. She was pronounced dead at the scene.
Vigo County Jail Log: Dec. 10, 2013
The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Monday and Tuesday, based on jail records.
- More Local & Bistate Headlines
- Family escapes early morning fire