Should Indiana children wait until they are 7 years old before they step into a classroom?
That’s a question that state Senate Minority Leader Tim Lanane thinks is worthy of a vigorous debate in the next legislative session.
Lanane, of Anderson, called a press conference last week to announce a plan, backed by Indiana Senate Democrats, to create a universal early childhood education program in Indiana and lower the state’s mandatory school age to 5 from 7.
But he didn’t capture as much attention as he’d hoped, for a couple of reasons: One, because the day’s news was dominated by another Associated Press story alleging wrongdoing by former state schools chief Tony Bennett. Two, because the Senate Democrats’ call for the state to invest millions of dollars into educating some of its youngest citizens is an idea that’s been floated — and failed — before.
Lanane, though, is an optimist. Soft-spoken, thoughtful, and low-key, he’s somewhat of a heretic in this current brutal age of partisan politics. When asked about the timing of his announcement, he explained: “We find these ideas take a while.” By that, I’m assuming he means public-policy ideas that have some complexity to them.
The right age for children to start school and the role the state should play in funding early childhood education seems worthy of the “good, old-fashioned legislative debate” for which Lanane has called.
It’s a debate going on right now in England, only turned upside down: Some education reformers there want to push up the mandatory age that children start school, from its current 5 to 7. Their argument: Early schooling is causing “profound damage” to children because it robs them of their time to play and be creative by forcing them into too much rigor and regimen too soon.
The argument on this side of ocean has long been a different view. Early childhood education advocates here say early schooling can have a profoundly good impact on children’s later success in school and go a long way to closing the achievement gap between rich and poor.
Lanane is particularly interested in closing that achievement gap, which shows up time and time again for schoolchildren in Indiana — one of 11 states that doesn’t put public funds into pre-kindergarten programs.
Earlier this month, the state Department of Education released the results of the IREAD-3 test, which measures the reading proficiency of third-graders. Ninety-four percent of white students passed the test. Only 81 percent of black students did. Only 74 percent of children who don’t speak English as their native language passed IREAD-3, and that was only after students who failed the test the first time received intensive remediation. That kind of gap echoes on every standardized test administered to Hoosier schoolchildren.
Of course, for the conversation on early childhood education to go forward, it will require the blessing of the Republicans, who hold a super-majority in both the House and Senate. Lanane may have a prayer: It was House Republicans who tried, but failed, to get $14 million put into the state budget to pay for a two-year pilot project to provide a high-quality, pre-kindergarten program for children from low-income families.
Money is the big stumbling block: Lanane estimates it may cost up to $200 million a year for local schools to offer pre-kindergarten to the estimated 180,000 children who would be eligible. That’s a fraction of the $7 billion that now goes to Indiana’s K-12 schools.
Here’s another piece of the conversation that may be coming on this issue: President Obama wants to spend about $75 billion to expand pre-kindergarten education nationwide, with much of the money coming from a federal tax increase of 94 cents a pack on cigarettes. States could tap into that national account if they agreed to contribute a portion of the cost for expanding early childhood education in their schools.
Maureen Hayden covers the Statehouse for CNHI, the Tribune-Star’s parent company. She can be reached at email@example.com.
Should Indiana children wait until they are 7 years old before they step into a classroom?
- Local & Bistate
Indiana makes marginal improvement in ‘Kids Count’
A new national report says the well-being of Indiana’s children has improved somewhat, but improvement in a key area might be overstated because of a quirk in the state’s reading rules.
Lowe’s expected to announce Indianapolis facility
Home-improvement retailer Lowe’s is expected to announce what state officials are calling a major development in Indianapolis.
Motorcyclist airlifted after Vigo County crash
A motorcycle crash in southern Vigo County remains under investigation.
Fire damages West Terre Haute house
A West Terre Haute house fire is under investigation.
Passenger dies in Greene County motorcycle wreck
A Linton woman has died in a Monday motorcycle crash on Indiana 157 north of Worthington.
UPDATE: Man dies in Raccoon Lake drowning
A Veedersburg man has died after resuscitation attempts were unsuccessful following his drowning Monday at Raccoon Lake in Parke County.
- Sports — What’s going on
Troubled bridge over water
For years, the iconic, arched foot-bridge at Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College had been the backdrop for pictures of newlyweds, prom-goers and Woodsies.
Pool construction bids, principals approved
After more than a year of discussion, debate and planning, work on the new Vigo Schools Aquatic Center at Voorhees Park is expected to begin today.
‘Launch’ pad for creativity
In an effort to foster entrepreneurs to begin and grow their ideas into a start-up business in Vigo County, “Launch Terre Haute” will host a co-work open house Wednesday.
Gelato at 12 Points
Coffee and gelato are now on the menu on Terre Haute’s north side.
Man pulled from Raccoon Lake
Indiana Conservation divers recovered a Veedersburg man reportedly submerged Monday afternoon at Raccoon Lake in Parke County.
Mall evacuated after bomb threat
The Meadows Shopping center was evacuated about 5 p.m. Monday after police received a report of an alleged bomb threat.
UPDATE: Faulty brakes blamed for bus crash
Police in Knoxville, Tenn., confirmed Monday that a Clay County church bus involved in a fatal crash last week had faulty brakes.
Police in Indy nab 2nd suspect in homicide case
A second man has been arrested in connection with a homicide in Greene County. The Indiana State Police confirmed that Jason Lee Caldwell, 35, was arrested Monday morning by Indianapolis police.
Police credit public tips for meth lab bust
Tips from the community helped lead to the arrest of a Terre Haute woman on charges including the manufacture and possession of methamphetamine.
Vigo County Council OKs tax abatements
Two companies received final approval from the Vigo County Council Monday for 10-year real and personal property tax abatements.
Four dead after five-vehicle crash on Interstate
Interstate 55 northbound near Joliet, Illinois, was closed Monday night after a four-fatality, multi-vehicle crash, Illinois State Police said in a press release.
Police: Brakes on church bus involved in fatal crash were faulty
Investigators confirmed there was a problem with the brakes on a Clay County church bus involved in a fatal accident last week in Knoxville, Tenn.
Dog attacks and kills Indiana baby in Ohio
DAYTON, Ohio (AP) — Authorities say a 7-month-old boy attacked and killed by a dog in southwestern Ohio was from Indiana.
Vigo County Jail Log: July 21, 2014
The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Friday, Saturday, Sunday and Monday, based on jail records.
New alcohol charge against John Mellencamp’s son
BLOOMINGTON, Ind. (AP) — The 20-year-old son of rock star John Mellencamp faces an underage drinking charge while awaiting resolution of charges that he and his brother seriously injured a man in a fight.
Dump truck crash kills 1, closes Indiana highway
FRENCH LICK, Ind. (AP) — State police say a crash that killed a dump truck driver closed a southern Indiana highway for several hours as crews worked to remove the vehicle from the roadway.
Update: Second man in police custody in connection with Greene County homicide
A second man has been arrested in connection with a reported homicide in Greene County. The Indiana State Police confirmed that Jason Lee Caldwell, 35, was arrested this morning by Indianapolis police.
Capitol Crossroads: Indiana Democrats deal with education split
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — On the face of it, the battles between Democratic Schools Superintendent Glenda Ritz and supporters and staff for Republican Gov. Mike Pence have been a unifying force for Indiana Democrats. But the scrapping has exposed a deep rift within the party over how students are educated.
Restaurant Inspections: July 21, 2014
June 30-July 4
Prosecutors: Expungement law has good, bad sides
BLOOMINGTON, Ind. (AP) — An Indiana law allowing some criminals to have their records expunged is drawing mixed reviews from judges and attorneys, who say parts of the law don’t make sense.
Tour de force
Pedal by pedal, a group of cyclists endured the hot summer sun and braved varying Indiana terrain on a mission to support survivors of law enforcement officers killed in the line of duty.
Living in a dream
“Welcome to the dream home!”
These were the words that greeted guests on Sunday as they entered a white, two-story home on the east side of Terre Haute.
MIKE LUNSFORD: Lake Michigan’s ‘Wonderful World of Color’
Despite the beauty around us, Joanie and I thought of television as we sat on a gorgeous Michigan beach one evening last week.
- More Local & Bistate Headlines
- Indiana makes marginal improvement in ‘Kids Count’