Should Indiana children wait until they are 7 years old before they step into a classroom?
That’s a question that state Senate Minority Leader Tim Lanane thinks is worthy of a vigorous debate in the next legislative session.
Lanane, of Anderson, called a press conference last week to announce a plan, backed by Indiana Senate Democrats, to create a universal early childhood education program in Indiana and lower the state’s mandatory school age to 5 from 7.
But he didn’t capture as much attention as he’d hoped, for a couple of reasons: One, because the day’s news was dominated by another Associated Press story alleging wrongdoing by former state schools chief Tony Bennett. Two, because the Senate Democrats’ call for the state to invest millions of dollars into educating some of its youngest citizens is an idea that’s been floated — and failed — before.
Lanane, though, is an optimist. Soft-spoken, thoughtful, and low-key, he’s somewhat of a heretic in this current brutal age of partisan politics. When asked about the timing of his announcement, he explained: “We find these ideas take a while.” By that, I’m assuming he means public-policy ideas that have some complexity to them.
The right age for children to start school and the role the state should play in funding early childhood education seems worthy of the “good, old-fashioned legislative debate” for which Lanane has called.
It’s a debate going on right now in England, only turned upside down: Some education reformers there want to push up the mandatory age that children start school, from its current 5 to 7. Their argument: Early schooling is causing “profound damage” to children because it robs them of their time to play and be creative by forcing them into too much rigor and regimen too soon.
The argument on this side of ocean has long been a different view. Early childhood education advocates here say early schooling can have a profoundly good impact on children’s later success in school and go a long way to closing the achievement gap between rich and poor.
Lanane is particularly interested in closing that achievement gap, which shows up time and time again for schoolchildren in Indiana — one of 11 states that doesn’t put public funds into pre-kindergarten programs.
Earlier this month, the state Department of Education released the results of the IREAD-3 test, which measures the reading proficiency of third-graders. Ninety-four percent of white students passed the test. Only 81 percent of black students did. Only 74 percent of children who don’t speak English as their native language passed IREAD-3, and that was only after students who failed the test the first time received intensive remediation. That kind of gap echoes on every standardized test administered to Hoosier schoolchildren.
Of course, for the conversation on early childhood education to go forward, it will require the blessing of the Republicans, who hold a super-majority in both the House and Senate. Lanane may have a prayer: It was House Republicans who tried, but failed, to get $14 million put into the state budget to pay for a two-year pilot project to provide a high-quality, pre-kindergarten program for children from low-income families.
Money is the big stumbling block: Lanane estimates it may cost up to $200 million a year for local schools to offer pre-kindergarten to the estimated 180,000 children who would be eligible. That’s a fraction of the $7 billion that now goes to Indiana’s K-12 schools.
Here’s another piece of the conversation that may be coming on this issue: President Obama wants to spend about $75 billion to expand pre-kindergarten education nationwide, with much of the money coming from a federal tax increase of 94 cents a pack on cigarettes. States could tap into that national account if they agreed to contribute a portion of the cost for expanding early childhood education in their schools.
Maureen Hayden covers the Statehouse for CNHI, the Tribune-Star’s parent company. She can be reached at email@example.com.
Should Indiana children wait until they are 7 years old before they step into a classroom?
- Local & Bistate
Indy developer interested in vacant ISU towers
The walls of Indiana State University’s Statesman Towers won’t be tumbling down anytime soon, despite a planned demolition that is now on hold.
Terre Haute gives out art grants
The City of Terre Haute backed its support of local arts organizations with funding on Wednesday, as grants totaling $21,500 were presented to seven nonprofit organizations.
The extra step: Feed company gets special certification
Graham Feed Co. in Terre Haute has attained a Safe Feed/Safe Food Certification from the American Feed Industry Association.
Otter Creek Twp. considering $1.5M bond
Otter Creek Township officials will conduct a public hearing today on a proposed $1.5 million bond issue to construct a new seven-bay firehouse to replace a current building in North Terre Haute that sits in a flood zone.
MARK BENNETT: Walk of Fame inductee would stand tall in any era
Unlike most of us, Amory Kinney didn’t let the wall around his comfort zone grow taller as time passed.
Networking at Schmooza Palooza event
The Terre Haute Chamber of Commerce hosted its Schmooza Palooza, an annual Evening Networking Expo, on Wednesday at The Landing in Terre Haute. The event is part of Business After Hours and part Business Networking Expo.
Parks Dept. warns of heavy traffic
The Terre Haute Parks and Recreation Department is reminding residents of increased traffic during December in the area of Deming Park on the city’s east side.
City Council considering synthetic drug ordinance
The Terre Haute City Council will be looking tonight at a proposal designed to curb synthetic drug sales and access for minors to tobacco and drug paraphernalia.
Two charges with child neglect released from jail
Two individuals arrested recently for child neglect have been released from the Vigo County Jail and ordered to have no contact with their children.
Police seek help in solving homicide as anniversary approaches
Tips in an unsolved homicide are still being sought, as the one-year anniversary approaches in the death of a Sullivan County man.
Area Plan proposes change to city building code
The Vigo County Area Plan Commission on Wednesday voted to recommend a proposed amendment to the Terre Haute City Code to clarify requirements for new buildings that would be built in downtown Terre Haute in the future.
Indiana mayors will fight to keep business tax
Mayors from across Indiana are gearing up for a fight to preserve a state business tax that produces nearly $1 billion in annual revenue for local governments, libraries and schools.
Republican leaders in the Statehouse say getting rid of the business personal property tax would lure manufacturers and other big job-creators to the state. But a chorus of mayors say the loss of revenue would hit communities already struggling with the impact of state-imposed property tax caps.
Vigo County Jail Log: Dec. 4, 2013
The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Tuesday and Wednesday, based on jail records.
Indiana AFL-CIO ousts leader from right-to-work fight
TERRE HAUTE — The Indiana State AFL-CIO has elected a new president, replacing the labor union’s leader who directed its unsuccessful campaign to block passage of the state’s right-to-work law.
Be alert on I-70 for lane restrictions
CLAY/PUTNAM/VIGO COUNTIES – The Indiana Department of Transportation asks motorists to be alert for lane restrictions on I-70 through Dec. 14.
Tip reveals active meth lab
TERRE HAUTE — Acting on an anonymous tip, Indiana State Police troopers from the Putnamville Post Meth Suppression Team found remnants of an active meth lab on Tuesday in a residence in the 3000 block of North 15 1⁄2 Street.
Unsolved homicide approaching one-year mark
Tips in an unsolved homicide are being sought as the one-year anniversary approaches in the death of a Sullivan County man.
White wonder: Snow ‘just adds to atmosphere’ of Miracle on 7th Street
Snow showers are expected to blanket downtown Terre Haute on Friday – just in time for the holiday wonder of Miracle on 7th Street.
SMWC names sports complex after late Sister
The new Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College Sports and Recreation Center will be named after the late Sister Jeanne Knoerle, the college’s 12th president.
Two Sullivan County school districts to get $1 million
Northeast and Southwest Sullivan school districts each will receive more than $1 million as part of a settlement in a federal securities fraud lawsuit.
State agency opposes limited unemployment benefits plan
A coalition of business and labor groups want Indiana legislators to expand unemployment benefits to partially furloughed workers, but the proposal faces opposition from the state agency that would implement it.
Buskirk pleads guilty for role in teen’s murder
A Greene County man appeared in court Tuesday morning to admit his involvement in the murder of a Linton teenager last summer.
Driver injured after swerving to avoid deer
A Jasonville man was injured in an early Tuesday crash south of Riley.
City man who led police on chase still loose
Authorities are still looking for a man who led police on a lengthy chase across the city Monday afternoon.
Bikes for Tykes needs donation
The Exchange Club of Terre Haute’s 16th annual Bikes for Tykes fundraiser needs donations to assist in providing bikes and helmets to Wabash Valley children.
I-70 westbound open again following evening crash
Interstate 70 west-bound, after being closed Tuesday due to an accident in Putnam County, opened again to traffic at about 7:30 p.m.
Vigo County Jail Log: Dec. 3, 2013
The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Monday and Tuesday, based on jail records.
Driver injured after swerving to avoid deer, hitting tree
A Jasonville man was injured in an early morning crash today in Vigo County.
Riley firefighters responded to the scene on Louisville Road about 1.5 miles south of Riley.
Ley sentenced to 12 years for 2012 death of motorcyclist
“It’s very hard to find what justice should be,” said Vigo County Judge Michael Rader after listening to two hours of emotional testimony Monday in the case of Travis Ley, a Terre Haute man convicted of driving under the influence of alcohol and drugs and causing the death of one young man and serious injuries to another.
Christmas lights set park aglow
Snoopy is ready to fight the Red Baron, and singing snowmen are playing hits by The Rolling Stones at this year’s Christmas in the Park in Deming Park.
- More Local & Bistate Headlines
- Indy developer interested in vacant ISU towers