News From Terre Haute, Indiana

Local & Bistate

October 21, 2012

Indiana ID process not always easy

Some find gathering documents required by BMV time consuming

TERRE HAUTE — By the time Margaret Pabst returned to the Bureau of Motor Vehicles branch in Terre Haute for a fourth time, she was ready to scream.

In all, she made five trips to the BMV, one to her bank, and a trip to the Vigo County Annex before she was able to obtain the documents she needed for her new SecureID Indiana driver’s license.

But, by then, “I was not a happy camper,” she said.

In light of Indiana’s law requiring voters to show a government-issued photo ID to cast a ballot, Pabst said she wondered whether someone without her time and resources could have obtained the ID needed to vote.

She doubts it.

“I don’t see how they could,” she said.

The kind of ID Pabst obtained is called a SecureID and is the type of identification required for people new to the state and first-time drivers. Those with existing licenses can just renew them, receiving what the BMV calls a “legacy” license.

The only difference between a SecureID and a regular driver’s license is the gold star adorning the former. Otherwise, they look like any other driver’s license.

At this point, SecureIDs are optional for people who already have an Indiana driver’s license. Eventually, however, everyone is likely to need a SecureID, said Dennis Rosebrough, deputy commissioner for external affairs for the Indiana BMV at Indianapolis. That’s because of the federal government’s Real ID law, set to take effect next year. That law, which is being challenged by state governors and others, would require birth certificates and other proofs of identity before any state can issue an ID.

Not always easy to comply

In 2005, Indiana legislators passed a bill requiring Hoosiers to show a government-issued photo ID to vote. Republicans said it was intended to prevent voter fraud. Democrats said it would disenfranchise the poor, elderly and disabled people. The bill passed along party lines, 52-45.

A little more than a year ago, Sister Hannah Corbin, a Sister of Providence, moved to Indianapolis from Vigo County and needed a new driver’s license in order to register to vote in her new community. She was not new to the state, nor was she a first-time driver, so a regular “legacy” license was all she needed. Nevertheless, it was an uphill climb.

To get her license, Corbin needed two documents proving her new address. She obtained one, a change-of-address confirmation, from the post office. But finding a second document was much more of a challenge. Most people use a utility or credit card bill. Corbin, who lives in a group setting with other Sisters of Providence, had neither.

After much frustration, Corbin finally obtained a paycheck stub from her employer, something that was not as easy as it sounds because she has direct deposit. In all, the process required several weeks of effort and a total of three trips to the BMV.

For someone without her access to a vehicle, a computer, a printer and time flexibility, “it would have been really difficult” to get even a non-secure ID, Corbin said. “That’s what really surprised me.”

“We’ve worked with them,” the BMV’s Rosebrough said of the Sisters of Providence, adding that, since that incident, the BMV has tried to make improvements that would account for such situations.

“We implemented this in 2010,” he said. “Certainly, as we’ve lived with this, we’ve gotten smarter in how to do things and what to look for.”

Other cases

But there are plenty of other examples of people having trouble getting an ID to vote.

A U.S. District judge recently ordered the Indiana BMV to conduct a hearing for Joesph Worley, a Muncie man who lost his license in 2008 due to a drunk-driving conviction. Since then, Worley has been unable to get an ID card to vote because the name on his Social Security card and his birth certificate do not match.  The name on his birth certificate reads “Joseph Alan Ivey,” but his name on a Social Security application completed by his mother a year later, after she had married her son’s biological father, reads “Joesph A. Worley.” To sort out the confusion, Worley has hired a lawyer and may need to change his name to get an ID, according to the Indianapolis Star.

In May’s primary election, a Vigo County resident was required to cast a provisional ballot because she was unable to get an Indiana driver’s license after moving back to the state from Missouri. New residents must get the state’s SecureID. A divorce meant additional documents were needed and the woman was unable to get the license before Election Day.

Vigo County Clerk Pat Mansard, a Democrat, is strongly opposed to Indiana’s voter ID law, saying it places unnecessary barriers in the way of people wishing to vote. Speaking to the Tribune-Star during the May primary season, Mansard told of an elderly man who showed up to vote without an ID and was offered a provisional ballot. When the man learned he would need to return to the courthouse within two weeks with proof of his identity to make his vote count, he decided it would not be worth the trouble, Mansard recalled.

BMV in the middle

The BMV had nothing to do with passing the state’s voter ID law, but the agency is deeply involved in making the law work in practice. The law requires the BMV to issue, free of charge, Indiana photo ID cards to anyone 18 and older who has the proper documentation.

There are hundreds of thousands of such cards currently in circulation, Rosebrough said.

Right before an election, the Terre Haute BMV office on Margaret Avenue sees a slight increase in requests for ID cards, said Dena Pastorius, team leader at that branch. However, sometimes the people seeking a card are under the mistaken impression they require one in addition to their driver’s license in order to vote, she said. A driver’s license or an ID card can be used for voting, but people are not allowed to have both.

In recent years, Indiana saw the biggest spike in issuing state ID cards in 2008, the year of the last presidential election. That year, the state BMV issued nearly 61,000 ID cards. That figure has dropped steadily each year since, reaching just 44,000 last year, according to figures provided by the state BMV.

Most customers of the BMV are sympathetic to the requirements currently in place to receive a new driver’s license or ID card, Rosebrough said. It can be an inconvenience, but it helps prevent identity theft and, in the wake of 9/11, national security is involved, he said.

“For the minor inconvenience that some people need to incur, we think that the integrity of the credentials issued by the State of Indiana … is worth those additional steps that someone might have to take,” Rosebrough said. “I think the public understands why it’s important.”

Spreading to more states

Secure photo IDs are one thing, but requiring someone to show one on Election Day in order to cast a vote is something else. Presently, that’s the law in Indiana and a growing number of states.

In 2008, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld Indiana’s law, rejecting a challenge brought by the Indiana Democratic Party. Writing for the court’s majority, Justice John Paul Stevens stated that any political issues raised by the law were trumped by the state’s desire to stop voter fraud.

But, in a minority opinion, Justice David Souter reiterated what Mansard and other Democrats have long said about the new law: No one has made the case that voter fraud was even taking place.

Still, tougher voter ID laws are starting to spring up all across the U.S., but many being challenged in court. There are now four states with strict laws like Indiana’s; five more states have passed such laws that have not yet gone into effect, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.

Since 2005, new voter ID laws have been passed in more than a dozen states, while governors in Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire and North Carolina vetoed laws similar to Indiana’s, the NCSL reported.

In all, well over half the states require some sort of ID to vote.

For Margaret Pabst, she can still feel the frustration she experienced gathering the documents she needed to get her SecureID, which she will be using to cast her vote Nov. 6.

Other who don’t have the wherewithal to cope with the hassle — or the patience to persevere — might be tempted to just give up.

Reporter Arthur Foulkes can be reached at (812) 231-4232 or

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Local & Bistate
  • Purdue Shooting2.jpg Purdue shooting leaves one person dead

    A Purdue University engineering student opened fire inside a basement classroom Tuesday, killing a teaching assistant and prompting officials to put the campus on lockdown, police and the university said.

    January 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • MET 042414 NEWELL SHIRT.jpg Katelyn Newell: One year later: Heartfelt celebration

    Nine-year-old Katelyn Newell may just be one of those few kids who have two “birthdays,” and Thursday she celebrated one of them. In the company of her family and classmates, Katelyn had a small party at her third-grade classroom at Deming Elementary School in celebration of the one-year anniversary of her heart transplant. Her family and friends call April 24 her “new heart birthday.”

    April 24, 2014 5 Photos

  • Purdue Shooting_Will.jpg THS grad Miller among students in adjacent building when shooting occurs

    Kris Miller and his roommate were in a computer lab of Purdue’s mechanical engineering building Tuesday when they received a call that a shooting had occurred next door.

    January 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Bosma Bosma moves gay marriage ban bill to friendlier committee

    Republican House of Representatives Speaker Brian Bosma sent a bill that proposes a constitutional ban on gay marriage to a more conservative-leaning legislature committee Tuesday, because it lacked support on the first committee to which it was assigned.

    January 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • MET012014 snowtracks.jpg We enter the deep freeze again

    If you had to step outside to get your newspaper this morning, you might have noticed it’s painfully cold once again.

    January 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • MET012014busses weir.jpg Levy redirects school funds

    If the new “protected levy” legislation goes into effect later this year, it would mean “a substantial reduction” in revenue for Vigo County School Corp. bus transportation, capital projects and bus replacement funds, according to the district’s chief financial officer.

    January 21, 2014 2 Photos

  • School debt levy redirects funds across Indiana

    School officials and state legislators from around the state are searching for ways to keep the school buses running — and children safe on the streets — pending the loss of millions of dollars for school transportation.
    More than 50 school districts in Indiana stand to lose at least 20 percent of their revenues for transportation, new buses and other big-ticket projects under a new law that requires them to first pay off their debts.

    January 21, 2014

  • MET 012114 DONNELLY BOARD.jpg VIDEO: Sen. Donnelly updates T-S editorial board

    Passage of a long overdue U.S. farm bill could be completed by the end of this month, Sen. Joe Donnelly, D-Ind., said Tuesday.

    January 21, 2014 1 Photo 1 Video

  • Vigo coroner tries again for salary increase

    After being denied last year, Vigo County Coroner Dr. Susan Amos is again seeking to have her county salary increased to match that of several other county office holders.

    January 21, 2014

  • MET 042414 DUKE BURGER.jpg Duke plans major move

    Duke Energy plans to move an oversized transformer from Terre Haute to Rockville on Monday, starting at 8:30 a.m., an action that will temporarily close sections of some roads in Vigo and Parke counties.

    April 24, 2014 2 Photos

  • Coats Daviess Coats to join GOP senators calling for Russian sanctions

    U.S. Sen. Dan Coats wants tougher sanctions against Russia for its growing involvement in Ukraine, despite signs of wariness back home.

    April 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • IMG_20140423.jpg ATV accidents send two to hospitals

    Two unrelated ATV accidents Wednesday in different parts of Vigo County sent two people to the hospital.

    April 24, 2014 2 Photos

  • NCAA board endorses more power for big schools

    INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — The NCAA’s board of directors endorsed a proposal today giving schools in the five largest football conferences more autonomy and more voting power in changing rules within the organization.

    April 24, 2014

  • Gun control supporters send message to NRA

    INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — About two dozen gun control supporters gathered today on the eve of the annual National Rifle Association convention in downtown Indianapolis to ask the gun rights organization to help stem a rising tide of homicides in the city.

    April 24, 2014

  • Popular Indiana dune to remain closed indefinitely

    MICHIGAN CITY, Ind. (AP) — Officials say a popular 126-foot high sand dune at Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore will remain closed indefinitely while scientists continue trying to determine what caused an Illinois boy to become buried under 11 feet of sand.

    April 24, 2014

  • Vigo County Jail Log: April 24, 2014

    The following individuals were booked into the Vigo County Jail by area law enforcement on Wednesday and Thursday, based on jail records.

    April 24, 2014

  • ATV rollover.jpg Teen seriously injured in ATV rollover

    At about 5:53 p.m. on April 23, Vigo County Sheriff’s deputies responded to an ATV crash in the 10200 block of South Trueblood Place in southern Vigo County.

    April 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Camm Steidl ISU Justice system questioned

    David Camm says that when he looks critically at the Indiana State Police today, he sees arrogance, ego and the desire for personal — even monetary — gain.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Death certificate delay angers Health Board

    The Vigo County coroner is not signing death certificates in a timely manner as required by law, according to the Vigo County Health Department.

    April 23, 2014

  • MET042314 glove.jpg MARK BENNETT: The memories from a baseball mitt fit like a glove

    Man hasn’t developed the technology for time travel.
    The smell of your old baseball glove can come pretty close, though.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • Former Parke County teacher arrested on felony charges

    A former Montezuma Elementary teacher — who also had served as president of the Southwest Parke Education Association — was arrested Wednesday on felony counts related to alleged missing funds, according to Indiana State Police.

    April 23, 2014

  • Bucshon has commanding money lead

    Incumbent U.S. Rep. Larry D. Bucshon of Newburgh has a commanding lead in campaign funds over fellow Republican Andrew McNeil of Freedom for the May 6 primary election, according to election reports from the Federal Election Commission.

    April 23, 2014

  • MET042314 arborday dell.jpg City’s first Arbor Day awards named

    Terre Haute and its citizens were recognized on Wednesday night for contributions to the urban forest.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • kersey turner Turner skips House ethics hearing

    House Speaker Pro Tem Eric Turner skipped a House ethics review Wednesday but claimed in filings submitted to the panel that he did nothing wrong when he fought legislation that would have cost him millions of dollars in profits.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Activity Fair is Saturday at park

    Are you looking for fun, afterschool and summer activities for your kids? You can review options a the Greater Terre Haute Afterschool Network Camps and Activities Fair from 8:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. Saturday at the Vigo County YMCA at Fairbanks Park, according to a press release.

    April 23, 2014

  • Children’s charity to conduct fundraiser this weekend

    March for Babies — the March of Dimes premier fundraising event that benefits all babies — will step off Saturday morning at ISU’s Memorial Stadium on the east side of Terre Haute.

    April 23, 2014

  • Villa Grove High School students win state anti-drinking PSA contest

    The State of Illinois on Wednesday announced that students from the eastern Illinois’ Villa Grove High School won the Illinois Liquor Control Commission’s statewide video public service announcement contest. The announcement ceremony at the Douglas County school also served as the statewide kickoff for this spring’s Your Actions Matter! underage drinking awareness campaign.

    April 23, 2014

  • For Wrigley, it’s party of a century

    CHICAGO (AP) — For Wrigley Field, it really was the party of a century.
    Exactly 100 years after the Chicago Federals pounded the Kansas City Packers in the first game at the Chicago ballpark, Wrigley got quite the birthday bash this afternoon.

    April 23, 2014

  • Emmert supports more efficient, effective NCAA

    INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — NCAA President Mark Emmert believes college sports can address the concerns of union organizers without changing the entire model.

    April 23, 2014

  • Former Parke County teacher, president of teachers’ association, arrested for alleged forgery, theft

    A former Montezuma Elementary teacher — who also had served as president of the Southwest Parke Education Association — was arrested this morning on various felony counts related to alleged missing funds, according to Indiana State Police.

    April 23, 2014

Latest News Poll
AP Video
Raw: Obama Plays Soccer With Japanese Robot Admirers Flock to Dole During Kansas Homecoming Raw: Kangaroo Rescued From Swimming Pool Raw: 3 American Doctors Killed in Afghanistan Ukraine Launches Operation Against Insurgents Colleagues Mourn Death of Doctors in Afghanistan US Proposes Pay-for-priority Internet Standards Yankees' Pineda Suspended 10 Games for Pine Tar New Pictures of Ship That Sank in 1888 Raw: Kerry Brings His Dog to Work Raw: Girls Survive Car Crash Into Their Bedroom Raw: Obama Arrives at State Dinner in Tokyo Raw: Car Crashes Into San Antonio Pool Time Magazine Announces Top Influencers List Raw: Angry Relatives Confront SKorea Officials Alibaba IPO Could Be Largest Ever for Tech Firm Three U.S. Doctors Killed by Afghan Security Scott Brown Announces Run for U.S. Senate in N.H FDA Proposes Regulations on E-cigarettes Raw: Czech Man Narrowly Escapes Speeding Train
NDN Video
Grumpy Cat Not Impressed at "Idol" Is Shaquille O'Neal the World's Best Ex-Athlete? Raw: Obama Plays Soccer With Japanese Robot Behind The Tanlines Jersey Strong Part 2 BASE Jumpers Set World Record Screaming 2-year-old gets psyched at Penguins game Pineda: Put pine tar because he didn't want to hit anyone Beyonce on Her Biggest Influence Michael Strahan's First Day on "GMA" Clerk catches on fire after man throws Molotov Cocktail into Brooklyn store Amazon's Deal With HBO Leapfrogs Streaming Rivals Stephen Colbert Tells David Letterman His Plan for 'Late Show' Georgetown police officer filmed tripping students Viral: It's Not Pitbull - It's Amy Poehler! Recycling Highlights for Earth Day Lupita Nyong'o Named People's 'Most Beautiful' Peeps Launched into Outer Space NYPD's Twitter Request For Photos Backfires New HBO Go Commercials Capture Awkward Family TV Watching Raw: Leopard Bites Man in India

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
  • -


    March 12, 2010