Criticism of coroner ruling based on false assumptions
After having read the letter criticizing Vigo County Coroner Dr. Amos in the June 8 Tribune-Star, I felt compelled to respond to this unwarranted attack. In the letter, the author stated “Amos cannot see any connection between brain trauma resulting from being punched and kicked in the head and a subsequent ischemic stroke. Really?”
As someone with considerably more knowledge of this case than that of the letter’s author, let me point out a few relevant issues. For one, being severely beaten is not necessarily synonymous with brain trauma. In fact, the medical records provided by Union Hospital did not document any history of traumatic brain injury, but did in fact mention several other co-morbidities which are associated with stroke in young individuals.
The author also suggests that having a stroke under the age of 50 virtually never happens in the absence of trauma, although his own reference states that it increases the risk by 60 percent. From my calculations, a 60 percent increase over zero would still be zero. Obviously, there are strokes in individuals under 50. If not, there would not have been enough of a study population to compare those with and without prior trauma, and arrive at the 60 percent figure. Whereas “Dr. James Burke and colleagues have a slightly different point of view,” neither he nor his colleagues examined this particular patient or his medical records. As a Forensic pathologist, I have found that it is generally considered a fairly important consideration to do so before rendering scientific based conclusions.
Another major problem I have with this letter is that the author has based his conclusions about Dr. Amos on three assumptions, which are all seriously in error. First of all, he has assumed that the newspaper article regarding Dr. Amos’s decision was a comprehensive and thorough discussion of all facts in the case. As someone who has dealt with local media coverage of death investigations for nearly 30 years, I can assure you that this is a very dangerous assumption.
Local media gives a brief summary at best, keeps it simple for the average reader, and almost never provides all relevant information. Long detailed stories with all pertinent facts do not get published because of time and space considerations,
Secondly, the author in his attack assumes that Dr. Amos acted alone in making this determination. In reality, the determination was made after review of detailed medical records by myself and Union Hospital’s chief quality officer Dr. Bolinger, consultation with the Board Certified Neurosurgeon who treated the patient, and a complete autopsy. Only after all these medical investigators deliberated and discussed the various medical facts and findings, was the cause of death determined.
Finally, although the author cites a reference to a respected medical journal, he assumed that the best way to communicate this to Dr. Amos was in the form of a letter, submitted to the editorial page of the Tribune-Star, instead of a phone call or letter to her directly. Really?
— Roland M. Kohr, M.D., Forensic Pathologist, Terre Haute
Criticism of coroner ruling based on false assumptions
Readers’ forum: July 22, 2014
• Supt. Ritz has right to govern
• A tribute to a teacher
• Rep. Pelosi shows ‘bungling idiocy’
Readers’ forum: July 20, 2014
• ‘Hotel Indiana’ has a sour tune
• Kind words about the newspaper
• Some questions about RTL video
• No mercy for cop killers
• Crack down on gun violence
• Anti-Dem tirades mask GOP failures
• Important day for participants
• Appreciation for support
FLASHPOINT: Solve our border crisis
More than 60,000 unaccompanied alien children — mostly from Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador — have been apprehended on America’s southern border during this fiscal year.
Flashpoint: Will Gov. Pence be true to his word?
This is written in response to recent remarks made by State Board of Education members.
- Readers’ Forum: July 18, 2014
READERS’ FORUM: July 17, 2014
• Civil rights and burning cities
• Quality service from Baesler’s
FLAHSPOINT: Supt. Glenda Ritz ‘creating conflict’
It has been my pleasure for the past year to serve as the newest member of the Indiana State Board of Education. I bring a fresh perspective to the board as an attorney and business executive who served as Director of Economic Development under former Indianapolis Mayor Bart Peterson and President of the Indy Partnership, a regional economic development organization charged with recruiting new companies to our state.
Readers’ Forum: July 16, 2014
• The truth about property taxes
Readers’ Forum: July 15, 2014
• Are Fed policies hurting America?
• Staying true to code of respect
Readers’ Forum: July 14, 2014
• Where did the 61 cents go?
Readers’ Forum: July 13, 2014
• Telling the truth about smoking
• Larger energy bills on the way, thanks to EPA
• Embrace the compassion, not self-righteousness
• Wondering about country’s leaders
• New amendments have hurt country
- Readers’ Forum: July 11, 2014
READERS' FORUM: July 10, 2014
• Herb Faire a great success
• Appreciation for a ‘lovely angel’
• Thanks for stirring fireworks show
Readers’ Forum: July 9, 2014
• Don’t eliminate our six-day mail
• Zamperini death stirs memories
Readers’ Forum: July 8, 2014
• T-S ignores common decency
• Lighten up on Donald Sterling
• Time to reject Dems in Congress
• Fueling the EPA
Readers’ Forum: July 7, 2014
• The moral issue is major issue
Readers’ Forum: July 6, 2014
• Coats ignoring climate science
• Do those mustache posters exist?
• Utility rate freeze took determination
• What perversion is next in line?
• Opinions vary, but voters will decide
• This preaching must stop — now
• Golf fundraiser a huge success
- Readers’ Forum: July 4, 2014
Readers’ Forum: July 3, 2014
• Over the top on immigration
- Readers’ Forum: July 2, 2014
Readers’ Forum: July 1, 2014
• Defying the laws of God
• Correcting the written record
• Hands of $$ from Redevelopment
• Celebrity visit for celebration
Readers’ Forum: June 30, 2014
• Don’t be victim of home repair scam
• Ending unfair tax practices
Readers’ Forum: June 29, 2014
• The sexual revolution strikes again
• Country sinks to new lows
• Saddened by the headlines
• Opinions not same as facts
• Letter meets with approval
• The real ‘truth’ sometimes hurts
• Applause for great musical
• Raising minimum wage hurts us
• Gratitude to camp sponsors
• More to the city’s mosquito problem
- Readers’ Forum: June 27, 2014
Readers’ Forum: June 26, 2014
• Misunderstandings about the lovely, messy mulberry
Flashpoint: Address growing cyber threats
Over the past several months, we have seen firsthand that threats to our nation’s cyber security are real and growing.
- Readers' Forum: June 25, 2014
Readers’ Forum: June 24, 2014
• Be careful in extreme heat
• Public workers serve us well
• Show us those mustache posters
Readers’ Forum: June 23, 2014
• It’s not hate, it’s just the truth
• Lousing up a very good day
Readers’ Forum: June 22, 2014
• Traffic signals need attention
• Current, future state of Iraq
• ISU focusing on returning adult students
• Activist’s passion for a better world
• Don’t waste your vote yet again
- More Letters Headlines
- Readers’ forum: July 22, 2014