A closer look at low-level offenders in Indiana prisons reveals that few of them are first-time criminals.
A yet-to-be released study of state prison inmates convicted of Class D felonies — the lowest felony level in Indiana — shows they had an average of five prior criminal convictions.
The study also shows that of those first-time offenders who did go to prison on a Class D felony conviction, nearly 80 percent of them did so for committing a violent crime such as battery or domestic violence.
The study upends the premise that drove the sentencing reform effort that failed in the last legislative session — that prosecutors and judges were crowding state prisons with low-risk, first-time offenders.
“It shows we aren’t sending beginners to prison,” said David Powell, executive director of the Indiana Prosecuting Attorneys Council.
Boone County Prosecuting Attorney Todd Meyer, among those who pushed for the study, echoed Powell.
“The people in prison are those who need to be in prison,” Meyer said.
The study was conducted by the Center for Criminal Justice Research at Indiana University’s Public Policy Institute in Indianapolis. A final version of the report is slated to be released next week.
Center staff conducted the study at the direction of the Legislature’s Criminal Code Evaluation Commission, whose members plan to take up sentencing reform again in the next session.
While the study shows that 91 percent of Class D felons in the Indiana Department of Correction are repeat offenders, it also shows why many of them are there: on drug and theft charges. Most of the drug convictions involved dealing in marijuana, and over half the theft convictions involved stolen items worth less than $250.
Andrew Cullen, legislative liaison for the Indiana Public Defender Council, said the study shows there are too many people in prison due to drug and theft crimes.
“The data shows that we are incarcerating a lot of citizens who are nonviolent, low-level property offenders, and we believe there are other options that are much more effective in addressing that behavior,” Cullen said.
About 27,000 offenders are housed in state prisons run by the Indiana Department of Correction; about 15,000 are there on Class D felonies.
Cullen and other advocates of sentencing reform have argued that those low-level offenders are crowding prisons and taking up space that should be used for violent offenders.
The study shows that the state prisons are crowded with people who can’t — or won’t — stay out of trouble. More than half of the Class D felons in DOC prisons are there because they violated the terms of their probation or parole.
“These were people given the opportunity to succeed back in the community but who decided not to follow the rules,” said Floyd County Prosecuting Attorney Keith Henderson, a strong advocate for the study.
Don Travis, chief probation officer in Howard County and president of the Probation Officers’ Professional Association of Indiana, is one of the few non-legislators who sits on the Criminal Code Evaluation Commission.
“The question has been, ‘Are we putting the proper people in DOC?’ and this report indicates we are,” Travis said.
The study’s findings are important, especially to the state’s prosecutors, who were widely blamed for derailing legislation last year aimed at reducing the state’s prison population by sending more low-level offenders back to their home communities.
Local prosecutors balked at the notion that they were driving up the state’s prisons costs.
State Rep. Ralph Foley, R-Martinsville, and the retiring chairman of the Criminal Code Evaluation Commission, said the new study will be helpful if it sheds light on who needs to be in prison — and who’s better served by community-based corrections programs.
“This isn’t about saving money (in state prison costs),” Foley said. “It’s about making sure we’re spending the right amount of money in the right places.”
The Center for Criminal Justice Research study came in response to questions raised by prosecutors and some legislators to a January 2011 report from the Council on State Governments and the Pew Center on the States. That report, initially used as an argument for sentencing reform, showed Indiana’s prison population had increased more rapidly than surrounding states over the past decade and was on track to keep escalating at an enormous cost to the state budget.
But prosecutors questioned why that report used prison population numbers from 2000 to 2008, which showed a rise in prisoners, but didn’t use numbers from 2009 and 2010, which showed a leveling off of the prison population.
Prosecutors also questioned the report’s finding that about half of new prisoners in DOC facilities were people whose crimes fell into the least serious category, Class D felonies. Those numbers were used as basis for the sentencing reform bill that would have reduced penalties for low-level drug and property crimes and shifted those offenders out of state prisons and back into local jails and community corrections programs.
Maureen Hayden covers the Statehouse for the CNHI newspapers in Indiana. She can be reached at email@example.com.
A closer look at low-level offenders in Indiana prisons reveals that few of them are first-time criminals.
- State News
Indiana’s unemployment rate drops to 5-year low
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Indiana’s unemployment rate dropped to 7.5 percent for October, marking its lowest level since late 2008 as the recession deepened.
Indiana lawmakers proposing new day care rules
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Indiana day cares that receive federal money would face new requirements for training and staff-to-child ratios under bills three lawmakers plan to introduce in the next legislative session.
Pence asks Sebelius for meeting on health care
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Gov. Mike Pence has requested a meeting with Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius to discuss issues that may be blocking a federal approval of using the state’s health savings accounts to expand Medicaid coverage for needy people in Indiana.
MAUREEN HAYDEN: Democrat leaders want marriage amendment pulled
INDIANAPOLIS — Indiana’s Democratic leaders in the Statehouse called for their Republican counterparts to pull the controversial same-sex marriage ban amendment off the legislative table, urging them to focus their energies instead on education, the economy and jobs.
Chaotic education board raises ‘Rules’ questions
Amid the chaos and fighting that has become Indiana’s Board of Education meetings of late, the question has popped up: Why not follow Robert’s Rules of Order?
UPDATE: Ex-Indiana schools chief faces ethics complaint
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Former Indiana schools Superintendent Tony Bennett is accused of using state resources for political reasons in a complaint filed with the state’s ethics commission today.
Bayh among new advisers to Middle East think tank
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Former U.S. Sen. Evan Bayh is joining a Middle East think tank in Washington.
Gov. Pence issues proclamation declaring Larry Bird Day in Indiana
INDIANAPOLIS – Gov. Mike Pence today issued a proclamation declaring Saturday, Nov. 9 as Larry Bird Day in Indiana. The proclamation coincides with the official dedication of a 15-foot bronze statue of Bird at Indiana State University in Terre Haute.
MAUREEN HAYDEN: 'Return on Investment' report by Indiana Commission on Higher Ed compares value of college degrees
Indiana higher education officials have long been promoting the value of a college degree, but a new report shows some degrees are much more valuable than others.
Judge hears from AG in Ritz-board of ed legal tilt
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — A Marion County judge is considering Attorney General Greg Zoeller’s argument that state schools Superintendent Glenda Ritz cannot sue members of the State Board of Education without his permission.
Pence announces school safety grants
Flanked by fourth-grade members of the Ambassadors Club and student council at Cedar Elementary School here, Gov. Mike Pence announced more than $9 million in grants for schools statewide to enhance their security.
Ritz expects effort to diminish her authority
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Indiana Schools Superintendent Glenda Ritz, a Democrat, said Wednesday she is wary of what she sees as a broad effort by Republicans to strip her power, amid growing tension between her and the State Board of Education she nominally chairs.
Conservative think tank paid Daniels for speech
WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. (AP) — A Purdue University spokeswoman says school President Mitch Daniels was paid for a speech at a conservative Minnesota think tank’s fundraiser that some believe broke his pledge to avoid partisan politics.
Indiana, schools sue over IRS health overhaul rules
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Indiana and 15 public school districts are suing the Internal Revenue Service for allegedly overstepping its authority in imposing “employer mandate” regulations on state and local governments under the federal health care overhaul.
Congressman standing firm on government shutdown
Todd Rokita of Indiana’s Fourth Congressional District has been an outspoken opponent of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act — a k a Obamacare — since it was signed into law in 2010.
On Tuesday, the first day the federal government partially shut down in 17 years, the Republican congressman wasn’t backing down.
Moderate rates set for Indiana insurance exchange
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Insurance plans in the coming federal health insurance exchange are expected to run from just under $100 per month for some single adults to close to $1,000 for family of four.
Democrats, labor question Indiana annuity change
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Democratic lawmakers and labor unions are asking the state pension board to delay a change in Indiana’s pension law they say will cost retiring workers thousands of dollars per year.
Indiana incomes continue behind national levels
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — New Census Bureau figures show that the income of Indiana households trailed the national median by 9 percent last year.
Pence issues flag directive to honor victims of Washington Navy Yard tragedy
INDIANAPOLIS — Gov. Mike Pence is directing flags at state facilities statewide to be flown at half-staff beginning today, Sept. 17, in honor of the victims of yesterday's shooting at the Washington Navy Yard. Flags should remain at half-staff until sunset Friday, Sept. 20.
Gov. Pence departs for 9-day trade mission to Japan
INDIANAPOLIS — Gov. Mike Pence is traveling to Japan for his first overseas trade mission as governor.
State’s reading test results show ‘achievement gap’ for at-risk students
More Indiana third-graders are passing the state’s reading proficiency test, but students who live in poverty or don’t speak English as their native language are failing the test at a higher rate than their counterparts.
Pension board change cuts retiree payouts
INDIANAPOLIS — Indiana lawmakers are pressing the head of Indiana’s pension system for answers about a change that would cut into how much retirees collect from their annuity plans.
New Indiana state auditor sworn into office
INDIANAPOLIS — Dwayne Sawyer has been sworn in as the new state auditor, making him the first black Republican to hold a statewide office in Indiana.
The state’s chief justice administered the oath to Sawyer during a ceremony today at the Statehouse.
New Indiana roadway map highlights tourist stops
INDIANAPOLIS — The new Indiana roadway map highlights many of the state’s tourism destinations.
Indiana DOE finds ‘manipulation’ of ‘A-F’ formula
INDIANAPOLIS — Indiana schools Superintendent Glenda Ritz says Department of Education staffers have found evidence of “manipulation” in the state’s school grading formula as part of a review stemming from a grade-changing scandal.
Official: Indiana infant mortality rate ‘horrible’
EAST CHICAGO, Ind. — Indiana’s top health official said the state’s infant mortality rate remains among the nation’s highest, despite efforts to combat what he called a “horrible” situation.
BMV to credit drivers overcharged for licenses
INDIANAPOLIS — Indiana’s Bureau of Motor Vehicles says motorists the agency charged too much for driver’s licenses will receive credit for the amount they were overcharged.
Court lets walk-out fines against House Democrats stand
INDIANAPOLIS — House Democrats who had to pay more than $100,000 in fines after they walked out of the Indiana Statehouse won’t get the help they sought from the Indiana Supreme Court.
Prison sentence of 12-year-old prompts new juvenile sentencing law
Three years ago, when 12-year-old Paul Henry Gingerich became the youngest person in Indiana ever sent to prison as an adult, his story gained international attention and sparked questions about whether children belong behind bars with grown-up offenders.
Ritz orders independent analysis of ISTEP results
Indiana Superintendent of Public Instruction Glenda Ritz has hired an outside expert to determine the validity of ISTEP+ test scores of nearly 80,000 students who were kicked offline while taking the high-stakes standardized test.
- More State News Headlines
- Indiana’s unemployment rate drops to 5-year low