The danger contained in these three simple words – “Right to Work” — is that they sound so innocent.
Who could be against having the right to work?
But there is nothing simple or innocent about a proposal with a documented history of cutting pay for workers, reducing benefits they earn to support their families, and reducing safety in their workplaces.
There is a very good reason it is called “Right to Work For Less.”
RTW For Less says: If you work at a place with union representation, you can reap the benefits that come from collective bargaining – salaries, health care – but refuse to pay your share of the costs of negotiating those benefits.
What would happen if an employee at a union business decided to stop paying dues, then gets injured on the job? This worker would get the same protections received by a worker who pays union dues, even though he doesn’t pay for those protections.
Does this sound fair to you? To be able to reap the benefits paid for by others? I don’t think so.
Mind you, this is an issue only in a union shop. If you don’t work for a union business, then you’re not paying dues or representation fees. The only businesses affected by RTW For Less laws are those that have chosen to negotiate with employee unions.
So if union shops are the only places affected, then how does the preservation of bargaining rights in Indiana keep any businesses from coming to our state?
During last summer’s hearings on RTW, not one shred of evidence was presented that proved any business refused to come to Indiana because we allow workers and businesses the freedom to collectively bargain.
Indiana’s top economic development official couldn’t name a single company that chose to locate elsewhere because Indiana refused to be a RTW For Less state.
There are no facts proving that Indiana could benefit by becoming a RTW For Less state. There have never been any findings that prove RTW For Less will help lure jobs to our communities.
By contrast, here are some easily verifiable facts:
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the average worker in a RTW For Less state makes substantially less than a worker in a non-RTW state. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, RTW For Less states have a higher poverty level. Workplace deaths are more than 50 percent higher in RTW For Less states, while workers injured on the job in those states receive lesser benefits.
Let’s look at the experiences of just two of the 22 RTW For Less states in this country.
Mississippi, which passed RTW For Less in 1954, consistently has ranked dead last in the nation in its ability to attract jobs. Its workers earn less than 80 cents on the dollar compared with the average U.S. worker.
Since Oklahoma passed RTW For Less in 2001, manufacturing jobs have disappeared. The Oklahoma Department of Commerce reported the state is attracting 33 percent fewer firms and jobs. Instead of losing jobs to competing states, Oklahoma jobs are going overseas, where no state can compete with the low wages offered in foreign countries.
Indiana already ranks in the top tier in the assets it provides to attract jobs. In the current economy, why would the Republican majorities at the Statehouse want to risk enacting a policy that could easily throw us back into the depths of recession? Furthermore, why would these majorities be so steadfast in their pursuit of a policy opposed by Hoosiers, according to a recent poll?
Because there is only one group that benefits from RTW For Less.
Big business. It reduces the costs of paying salaries and benefits to their workers, which increases their profits.
Hoosier workers already earn only 86 cents on the dollar, compared to other workers across this country. Bringing RTW For Less to Indiana will be just another step on our race to the bottom.
Yet Right to Work For Less will be offered by the Republican majorities in the 2012 legislative session as their grand plan to create jobs.
That may sound like a joke, but it becomes something far more serious when you hear supporters claim that RTW For Less will be our state’s way to find work for Hoosier veterans returning from service overseas.
Think about that for a minute. Here is the message we are sending these men and women:
You have put your life at risk defending our country. Here will be your reward.
There will be few new jobs. The jobs that are created will have low wages and benefits, and you’ll be working in a place where safety takes a back seat to putting more money in the pockets of your bosses.
Forgive me for thinking that Indiana can do a whole lot better.
State Rep. David Niezgodski (D-South Bend) is the ranking Democrat on the House Employment, Labor and Pensions Committee.
The danger contained in these three simple words – “Right to Work” — is that they sound so innocent.
FLASHPOINT: Where Congress falls short, and where it doesn’t
At a public gathering the other day, someone asked me how I’d sum up my views on Congress. It was a good question because it forced me to step back from worrying about the current politics of Capitol Hill and take a longer view.
Flashpoint: President should stop Medicare Advantage cuts
Virtually all elected officials — Republicans and Democrats — share the goal of increasing access to affordable health insurance and helping families receive the best coverage to meet their specific needs.
FLASHPOINT: Restoring trust, respect in schools rests in fundamentals
A recent Harris poll of 2,250 adults reveals a troubling educational trend.
Flashpoint: Everyone would benefit from responsibly expanding health coverage for Hoosiers
A medical epidemic is one of the worst scenarios a hospital can face — when a significant portion of the population is suddenly struck with a life-threatening illness.
FLASHPOINT: Now imperiled, Indiana’s leadership helped launch biodiesel success story
There’s been a lot of talk about ethanol lately, and the policy — known as the Renewable Fuel Standard, or RFS — that introduced renewables into our nation’s fuels mix.
FLASHPOINT: Local control over the business personal property tax good option
I have a tremendous respect for Indiana’s local leaders.
FLASHPOINT: Did legislators place bad bet on Common Core?
A comedian once observed that the reason they call it “horse sense” is because horses don’t bet on people.
FLASHPOINT: Manufactured statistics, exaggerated claims make meth battle more difficult
Indiana has many societal problems. One of the most serious is the use of methamphetamine. Meth destroys families, ruins lives and costs taxpayers millions of dollars in law enforcement and meth cleanup efforts.
FLASHPOINT: Study dissects tough tax issues on business equipment, machinery
Indiana’s Legislature first got serious about eliminating personal property taxes in 1966, when Hoosiers approved a constitutional amendment separating taxes on property and personal property.
FLASHPOINT: Hold all the congrats for this U.S. Congress
Now that Congress has its immense, $1.1 trillion bipartisan funding bill in hand, Capitol Hill is breathing easier. They ended the specter of a government shutdown for the moment and funded the federal budget for most of the year. The media has been commending Congress for finally doing its job.
FLASHPOINT: State has obligation to crack down on youth sexual assault
Children have the right to be safe. Yet in Indiana, girls are more likely to be sexually assaulted than almost anywhere else in the country.
FLASHPOINT: Economic prosperity means strong businesses and vibrant communities
Whether you are talking about college graduates looking for a first job, older citizens who are deciding where they want to live as they age, or new parents deciding on the right place to raise a family, future Hoosiers can afford to be picky.
FLASHPOINT: Marriage ban contrary to U.S. law and Christian faith
Central Christian Church has been part of the Terre Haute community since 1841 and an Open and Affirming congregation since 2006.
FLASHPOINT: Different day — same story
Heading into the 2014 legislative session, the argument again is being made — in a tired and worn way — that Indiana’s laws controlling the sales of alcohol are outmoded, inconvenient and circumspect.
FLASHPOINT: What are government’s essential functions?
Here are some questions regarding the distressed reaction by some in local government to Gov. Pence’s stated intent to eliminate business personal property taxes.
FLASHPOINT: No need to expand access to alcohol in Indiana
I am a homegrown Hoosier businessman. The state of Indiana has granted me the privilege, and the responsibility, of selling alcohol.
FLASHPOINT: America’s major policy shift on Iran
In a recent address to the nation, President Barack Obama acknowledged Iran “has been unwilling to meet its obligations to the international community.” In the same speech the president vowed to “prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon.”
FLASHPOINT: Dealing with hunger requires less rhetoric, more action
In November, millions of families in Indiana and across the nation saw their Supplemental Nutritional Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits cut through a planned phase-out of a temporary increase in funding that originally took place during the 2009 recession.
FLASHPOINT: Getting right with history
I am ornery enough to never much worry about whether I am on the “right” side of history.
FLASHPOINT: Dogged journalism is a blessing, not a curse
Let’s start with the obvious: A democracy needs intelligence agencies. It needs to know what’s happening in the world — and understand the plans of allies and enemies — to keep the nation prepared and secure.
FLASHPOINT: Same-sex marriage battle not good for state’s future
For those who can still bear to look, Indiana’s unemployment rate remains stuck above 8 percent.
FLASHPOINT: A pledge to work together with respect, civility
Indiana’s students and schools have made great progress in recent years. According to the latest scores from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), Indiana is improving at the second-fastest rate of any state in the country. We owe this progress to the hard work of our students, teachers and the parents and school reformers everywhere who have insisted that we hold ourselves to high standards.
FLASHPOINT: Putting children before politics
I very rarely write a response to an opinion article. However, when the title of the Indianapolis Star column says, “While Ritz, Board spar, children get hurt,” I feel compelled to clear the air.
FLASHPOINT: Prescription for Obamacare: delay employer mandates
An email I received from Daniel in Elkhart, Ind., summarizes the experience many Hoosiers are having with the recently launched Obamacare online health insurance marketplace:
FLASHPOINT: A common-sense Congress could strengthen our economy
My top priorities have always been to strengthen Indiana’s economy and to help create Hoosier jobs. We can all agree — Democrats and Republicans — that the recent government shutdown and the threat of failing to pay our nation’s bills were significant setbacks to this seemingly simple goal.
FLASHPOINT: How to improve the road ahead for our government
One of the more amazing spectacles in the days after the government shutdown ended was the obsession in Washington with who won and who lost in the showdown. Yes, the capital is focused on next year’s elections, but honestly! There was only one real loser, and that was the American people.
FLASHPOINT: Celebrating role of newspapers in protecting free speech
Where would we be as a nation without the freedom of speech?
FLASHPOINT: Hard-hitting ads are effective in preventing tobacco use, saving lives By
Reducing tobacco use is one of the most important things we can do to improve the health of Hoosiers. Education campaigns to alert of the dangers of tobacco use are critical, as are pointing them to resources to help them quit.
FLASHPOINT: A difficult decision to allow oil testing, drilling
Our current culture seems to tell us life’s struggle is all about good vs. evil and black-and-white decisions. The reality is that the hardest choices are those that aren’t clear cut. They’re the ones you can argue from either side but eventually must make based on only a slight edge. That is the kind of choice the Sisters of Providence had to make about whether to test for and drill for oil on our Mother House land.
FLASHPOINT: It’s time for an intervention
The American public has lost patience with Washington.
- More Flashpoint Headlines
- FLASHPOINT: Where Congress falls short, and where it doesn’t