INDIANAPOLIS — When it comes to first-year players in the National Football League, performance is always a hit-and-miss proposition.
If an NFL team can find a productive player from even half of the team’s picks from a particular year, the draft is considered a good one. Most coaches and player personnel directors, however, insist that it usually takes more than one year in order to determine if a draft has been truly successful.
But when it comes to this year’s Indianapolis Colts draft class, it’s not hard to see the talent that the team has brought in. From running back Donald Brown, the Colts’ first-round pick, to offensive guard/tackle Jaimie Thomas, Indianapolis’ last draft selection, they’ve been impressive for the most part.
With the team playing the Buffalo Bills this afternoon in the Colts’ 2009 regular-season finale, it’s probably as good a time as any to assess the group.
• First, the hits: Cornerback Jerraud Powers (third round), wide receiver Austin Collie (fourth round), and punter/kickoff specialist Pat McAfee (seventh round). All three have been valuable additions to the Indianapolis roster this season and have made key plays throughout the year.
• The misses: Defensive tackle Terrance Taylor (fourth round). The former University of Michigan defensive lineman was released at the end of training camp. He has been with the Carolina Panthers and Detroit Lions since being released in September.
• The jury is still out: Brown (first round), defensive tackle Fili Moala (second round), quarterback Curtis Painter (sixth round) and Thomas (seventh round).
Brown is clearly the best of this bunch, but injuries this year have slowed his development. If he can remain healthy, and improve as a pass blocker, he has more than enough ability to be a quality running back in the league.
Moala has not progressed as quickly as some would have hoped, although he has gotten more playing time over the last month of the season. Painter just hasn’t played much and was put in a tough situation in last week’s loss to the New York Jets. Thomas, meanwhile, has shown just enough upside to warrant keeping him around on the Colts’ practice squad.
Clearly, the diamonds in this year’s draft -- at least so far -- have proven to be Powers, Collie and McAfee. Powers has taken over at right cornerback with veteran Marlin Jackson sidelined for the rest of the season with a knee injury.
While he is nursing a sore hamstring now and has been out for the past two games -- and will most likely not play today against Buffalo -- the rookie from Auburn is sixth on the team in tackles with 71, has one interception, broken up nine passes, has forced one fumble and recovered a fumble.
“I think [Powers] has a real unique quality because he is a guy that is mature beyond his years in every aspect. He is a very settled individual, very focused. He’s conscientious and obviously skilled physically. But a guy that is always thinking and always seems to be in the right place at the right time,” said Colts coach Jim Caldwell.
“He followed the classic example of an individual that keeps getting better week-in and week-out. He’s had a little bit of a setback here as of late [with the hamstring injury] but he’ll back. And we anticipate he’ll play even better than he’s played previously.”
As for Collie, all the former Brigham Young standout has done this year is haul in 59 passes for 661 yards and seven touchdown passes (most receptions and touchdown catches by a first-year receiver in the NFL this season).
He ranks third on the team in receiving behind veterans Reggie Wayne and Dallas Clark. And he is currently having the fourth-best season by a Colts rookie in terms of receptions (Bill Brooks had 65 in 1986, followed by Marvin Harrison’s 64 in 1996 and Edgerrin James’ 62 in 1999). That’s not bad company to be in.
“Collie has really come in and filled a void that we had, just in terms of someone being able to play and play effectively in the slot. It was a position we weren’t quite certain of how it would end up. We knew we would have a pretty good player there, but to have a rookie perform the way he has performed is pretty unique. I think that’s because of how he works at it, he studies, he loves it and he’s been able to adapt,” Caldwell said.
“He keeps getting better. I think early in the season whenever we talked about him I’d always add a little caveat, ‘But, he has to keep getting better.’ He’s continued to do so. He catches the ball. He’s been good in terms of his run support blocking. All around, he’s been a good, solid player, and he keeps getting better. That is key.”
Perhaps the rookie with the biggest shoes to fill, literally, was McAfee. He’s averaged 44.2 yards overall and 38 yards net on 58 punts this season. He has placed 20 punts inside the opponent’s 20-yard line.
But in replacing longtime (and fan favorite) Indianapolis punter Hunter Smith, the first-year player from West Virginia not only has had to punt but he’s also taken over Smith’s role as the team’s holder for placekickers Adam Vinatieri and Matt Stover
Considering that he had never been a holder while in college, the affable McAfee has done just fine in that role. He was taught the nuances of holding in training camp by Vinatieri and his studies in that category have been enhanced by the addition of Stover.
What’s been equally as impressive has been Collie’s performance handling kickoffs for Indianapolis. He has 21 touchbacks so far this year, helping to bolster the Colts’ kickoff coverage units overall improvement this season.
“McAfee has been tremendous. He’s handling two duties for us [punting and holding on field goals and extra points]. That is very difficult for a guy in his first year to do what he has been able to do. You look at our numbers in terms of kickoffs for example, our numbers are a lot different than they were previously. He’s had a lot of touchbacks. That certainly does indeed help our defense. It makes a team have to drive 80 yards to score. The more often you can do that, make them go the long haul, it’s going to help you get them stopped. He’s helped a tremendous amount there,” the Colts coach said.
“His punting has been very good, solid. He’s certainly made a lot of big plays, placing the ball inside the 20-yard line on numerous occasions. He’s a guy that doesn’t get nervous. He loves what he is doing, and he continues to get better week-in and week-out. I think that is key. Neither one of those guys [McAfee and Collie] or Powers hit the proverbial wall, the rookie wall as we oftentimes say. They continue to get better.”
INDIANAPOLIS — When it comes to first-year players in the National Football League, performance is always a hit-and-miss proposition.
Heavy snow appears in forecast for Colts
Growing up in Houston, Texas, Andrew Luck doesn’t have a history of playing a lot of football in the snow or in snowy conditions. But if weather forecasts for this weekend remain on track, Sunday’s AFC battle between the Indianapolis Colts and Cincinnati Bengals may be severely tested by the weather.
Seizing the moment: Colts’ running back Brown comes through at end in first start of season
Donald Brown has bided his time this season as the Indianapolis Colts elevated Vick Ballard, Ahmad Bradshaw and Trent Richardson to the team’s No. 1 running back position.
An Ugly ‘W’ for Indy
Yes, it was an ugly game to watch.
Luck’s analysis: ‘Great job’ by defense and Vinatieri; ‘terrible job’ by offense and ‘by me’ — but he’ll take a win
Nobody had to tell the Indianapolis Colts that Sunday’s performance against the Tennessee Titans was far from perfect.
Colts looking for execution to climb out of funk
While the Indianapolis Colts are in a bit of a funk right now, losing two of their last four games by a combined score of 78-9 (38-8 to St. Louis, 40-11 last week at Arizona), don’t expect the team’s offensive and defensive coaching staffs to make changes, whether it’s scheme or personnel.
Colts seek to right ship against Titans
Another home game, another meeting with the Tennessee Titans. The Indianapolis Colts, fresh off last week’s 40-11 road loss to Arizona, know what’s at stake against the Titans on Sunday at Lucas Oil Stadium.
Colts ready to go back to work
If anybody expected Indianapolis Colts coach Chuck Pagano to start spewing fire to his players in the wake of Sunday’s 40-11 National Football League loss at Arizona, they would be largely disappointed.
For second straight game, Colts fail early and often in big loss
The Indianapolis Colts had 10 days off before facing the Arizona Cardinals.
It didn’t seem to do much good.
Struggling on both sides of the ball, the Colts put together a lackluster effort in the desert, leading to a 40-11 loss to the Cardinals on Sunday.
Arians faces his old team
The early pregame warmups that NFL teams go through are usually pretty routine.
Players and coaches usually spent the time loosening up, touching base with old friends who are with the other team. A few minutes chatting up an old buddy or college teammate and then its back to the matter of hand.
Arians latest to join Colts’ reunion tour
The 2013 NFL season has turned into a reunion tour, of sorts, for the Indianapolis Colts.
Colts’ Walden to appeal one-game suspension
Indianapolis Colts outside linebacker Erik Walden will be suspended for Sunday’s National Football League road game at Arizona, the NFL announced Monday.
Colts rally from 14-down, beat Titans 30-27
NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — The Indianapolis Colts keep digging themselves into early holes — and proving they know how to come back and win.
5 things to know as Colts rally, beat Titans
NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — The Indianapolis Colts know they have to stop falling behind early. It’s just a hard habit to break when they keep rallying for victories.
Colts looking for big-play receiver
When the Indianapolis Colts signed rookie wide receiver Da’Rick Rogers to the active roster Monday after a stint on the practice squad, it was just another indication that team officials aren’t completely happy with the way the Colts’ receiving corps has played over the last two weeks.
Colts looking to shift running game out of neutral
After getting off to a pretty good start running the football this season, the Indianapolis Colts find themselves stuck in neutral.
Indianapolis has had difficulty coming up with a consistent running attack over its last two games. That fact was never more in evidence that in last Sunday’s 38-8 National Football League loss to the St. Louis Rams.
Colts need to forget embarrassing loss, prepare for next game
Former Indiana State men’s basketball coach Tates Locke had a slogan that he liked to use when it came to putting bad games or bad performances on the back burner.
It’s safe to say that the Indianapolis Colts have been living on the National Football League edge for most of the past two years.
‘Can’t keep digging ourselves a hole’ — Pagano
Chuck Pagano Is usually a pretty even-tempered guy.
Colts back home, hoping to keep momentum going
The goal for the Indianapolis Colts in Sunday’s NFL home game with the St. Louis Rams is relatively simple. Just keep getting better.
Colts work magic again, find way to win
Good teams find a way to win. Bad or struggling teams usually find a way to lose. That’s as much of a reason — along with the play of quarterback Andrew Luck — as how the Indianapolis Colts staged their 10th fourth-quarter come-from-behind win over the past two seasons Sunday night in Houston.
Colts dodge Texans’ bullets
The Indianapolis Colts rallied for a 27-24 victory over the Texans on Sunday night after Houston coach Gary Kubiak collapsed leaving the field at halftime and was taken by ambulance to a hospital.
Colts: Road to division title leads through Houston
Never mind that the Houston Texans will come into Sunday night’s nationally televised game with the Indianapolis Colts with a 2-5 record. For Colts coach Chuck Pagano and his players, the Texans are the defending AFC South champions. In fact, Houston has won the division title the last two seasons. Enough said.
Back in stride: After bye week, Luck says Colts must overlook Texans’ 2-5 record
Vacation, in terms of a one-week bye, is now over. It’s back to work for the Indianapolis Colts, who will go into Sunday night’s nationally televised National Football League game (NBC, 8:30 p.m. kickoff) against defending AFC South champion Houston with a 5-2 record and a two-game lead in the division.
After big win over Broncos, Colts learn that standout receiver Wayne is out for season with knee injury
Chuck Pagano, like most head coaches in the National Football League, has become more or less accustomed to players getting hurt and having to miss significant time during a season. Unfortunately, that’s just part of the game. But the news Monday that wide receiver Reggie Wayne has been lost to a season-ending knee injury hit a little closer to home for Pagano for purely personal reasons.
Colts vs. Manning: Competing allegiances
Blue or Orange?
That was the question many fans grappled with as former Indianapolis Colts quarterback Peyton Manning returned to Lucas Oil Stadium — “the house that he built” — Sunday night for the Colts-Broncos football game.
Colts knock Broncos from unbeaten perch
Everybody expected a barnburner when the Indianapolis Colts and Denver Broncos hooked up in National Football League play on national television Sunday night.
Mixed emotions from Manning in wake of Indy return, Broncos loss
It was a bittersweet symphony for Denver Broncos quarterback Peyton Manning upon his return to Indianapolis.
TODD GOLDEN: Colts fans paid Manning ultimate tribute
Peyton Manning’s return to Indianapolis was many things — the return of a beloved prodigal son, a battle of Colts’ No. 1-draft-pick quarterbacks and last, but not least, the visit from one of the AFC’s last reminaing undefeated teams — but most of all, it could have been a battle for the Colts’ fans soul.
Showdown In Indy: A legend comes back to face his replacement
So just how do you follow a legend?
That’s the question Indianapolis Colts quarterback Andrew Luck gets asked pretty much on a daily basis.
Colts' Hamilton hoping to grind out long drives against Broncos
Pep Hamilton has a gameplan on how the Indianapolis Colts (4-2) can pull off an upset win over the undefeated (6-0) Denver Broncos on Sunday night.
The Colts’ first-year offensive coordinator, though, knows the task won’t be easy. After all, Denver comes to Lucas Oil Stadium for the nationally televised (NBC Sports, 8:30 p.m.) as the NFL’s most potent offense. The Broncos have scored 265 points so far, the most by any NFL team in the first six games of a season.
- More Colts Headlines
- Heavy snow appears in forecast for Colts