“What is the purpose of this season of buying and buying more?” asks Oliver Offenon.
“That’s a twisted view,” I respond. “It’s the season of giving. Buying is a necessary activity people engage in as they prepare to give.”
“If people made things, put some of themselves into their gifts,” Oliver says, “it would be different. Giving would be more personal, more significant.”
“What is more personal than your time?” I ask.
“Exactly!” Oliver declares. “Time spent making gifts is a most personal statement about the value of the relationship to the giver.”
“You’re thinking in terms of a romanticized 19th century world, not today’s America,” I say. “Few Americans are proficient in traditional crafts. Most people today don’t know how to work with wood or clay, with wool or cotton. Manufacturing in the 19th century replaced those skills so that there are few who can make furniture or knit sweaters in modern America.
“Mechanization increased production, standardized parts and made it possible for millions to enjoy quality material goods previously available to only the wealthiest.”
“It’s just not the same,” he says.
“It’s better than the past,” I reply. “Today a giver buys goods (like cell phones) that an ordinary person cannot make. The cost of the cell phone is the number of hours the giver works to earn the price of the cell phone.”
“It’s so impersonal,” Oliver objects.
“It is remarkably personal,” I insist. “For the money a worker earns s/he gets to choose from an enormous variety of goods and services. At the simplest level, a gift of money offers the recipient the opportunity to choose from a virtually limitless catalogue of goodies.
“The giver is saying, ‘Here are five hours of my life; use them as you choose.’”
“That’s vulgar,” Oliver protests.
“No,” I say softly. “That is liberating the recipient who can avoid the tyranny or ignorance of a giver who does not understand or approve the recipient’s choices.”
“It takes all the meaning out of gift giving,” Oliver says. “A gift should reflect the opinion the giver has of the recipient.”
“People should separate the idea of gifts from the concept of behavior modification or the amelioration of need,” I say. “When I give a gift of music, I am telling the recipient what I think s/he should be listening to. If I choose a band I know the recipient likes, I am endorsing the recipient’s choices.
“When I give warm gloves, I say the recipient does not have the necessities of winter. I am correcting her/his oversight or poverty.”
“What a perverse view you have of giving,” Oliver says. “For you a gift is a criticism, not a statement of affection. You don’t partake of the joy in giving and receiving.”
“I don’t see it that way,” I protest. “My views are just standard conservative economics.”
Morton Marcus is an independent economist, writer and speaker. Contact him at email@example.com.
“What is the purpose of this season of buying and buying more?” asks Oliver Offenon.
EYE ON THE PIE: Necessary truth: Reality not built on press releases
John Quill made his annual spring appearance last week and may stick around for another few weeks.
CHAMBER: Multi-generational workforce topic of seminar
Did you know that by 2015 nearly one-third of the workforce will be 50 or older? Did you know eight to 10 baby boomers expect to continue working at least part-time? Did you know millenials are the fastest growing part of society and constitute 25 percent of the workforce?
Stone Soup Creative brings business to Terre Haute
Award-winning graphic design agency Stone Soup Creative has brought its design, branding and marketing experience to Terre Haute.
Avoid the stress of Social Security fraud
April is Stress Awareness Month, but one thing that should never cause you stress is doing business with Social Security.
- BUSINESS BRIEFS: April 13, 2014
Old National Bank on ‘Most Ethical’ list
The Ethisphere Institute has recognized Old National Bank as a 2014 World’s Most Ethical Company.
Newsmakers: April 13, 2014
Each year, employees of the state of Indiana participate in the State Employees’ Community Campaign, during which employees are asked to donate to a charity of their choice through payroll deductions.
ASK SCORE: Profitability requires power management
Small business owners are always on the lookout for ways to improve the efficiency of their processes and tasks.
On the move: April 13, 2014
Michelle D. Mentzer
Gregory K. Luken
Purdue, IU churning out more patents, startups
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Fort Collins, Provo, Raleigh, Durham and Chapel Hill are household names in tech circles—cities known for birthing startup companies with well-paying jobs.
Social Security: Helping Americans with disabilities
The World Health Organization hosted the first World Health Assembly in 1948, and, beginning in 1950, every year the world comes together to observe World Health Day on April 7. Each year, World Health Day focuses on a particular subject of interest to global health. At Social Security, we focus on people’s health every day.
Business Cents: Bad managers equal bad employees, loss of productivity
There are many factors that impact and affect the performance of a company, but have you ever considered how bad managers actually affect employees and your company?
Rose return on investment 7th on PayScale list
A Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology education is a worthy investment, ranking seventh nationally, with a 20-year net return of $736,200, according to PayScale, Inc’s 2014 College Return on Investment Report.
Tip-A-Cop Wednesday in Terre Haute
Indiana State Police along with county and local law enforcement officers and Special Olympics Indiana team up with six Texas Roadhouse restaurants to benefit more than 11,000 Hoosier athletes with intellectual disabilities.
- Newsmaker: April 6, 2014
- On the Move: April 6, 2014
Get ahead of your personal paper chase
Forget everything you’ve read about the “paperless” office. Though our computers, PDAs and smart phones have digitized many aspects of daily life, paper is still very much with us.
- Briefly: April 6, 2014
Steady, not spectacular: U.S. jobs up 192K in March
WASHINGTON (AP) — U.S. employers added jobs at a solid pace in March and hired more in January and February than previously thought. Today’s government report sent a reassuring signal that the economy withstood a harsh winter that had slowed growth.
UPDATE: Casey’s investing $30M in new distribution center
Casey’s General Stores will locate a new distribution center in Vigo County, creating up to 185 new jobs by 2019.
UAP Clinic appoints new CEO
Union Associated Physicians Clinic announces the appointment of Ed Carne as chief executive officer. Carne started today, March 31.
EYE on the pie: Ideologies: Allegiance diverges at every level of government
Who should be in charge? Governments or private entities? If government, should it be the feds, the states or the locals? What level of government, if any, should control transportation, education, health care, libraries and almost anything else you can imagine?
Holiday, museum round out month for Young Leaders
Happy spring from Terre Haute Young Leaders. I hope last week’s snow is the last we see for a long time. Despite the climate and what seems to be a never-ending flu season, Young Leaders had a very productive March.
Locate important docs before severe weather
The Indiana Department of Homeland Security advises Hoosiers to locate important documents before disaster strikes. Having access to these documents can expedite the recovery process.
Wabash Valley College to host job fair April 16
Wabash Valley College is hosting a job fair from noon to 6 p.m. April 16 in the Spencer Sports Center in Mt. Carmel, Ill.
SOCIAL SECURITY: Dusting off your financial plan
Spring is officially here. Before you get started with your spring cleaning, perhaps another matter deserves some dusting off — that long-term financial plan.
SCORE: ‘Dancing near the revenue line’ management
Time is a precious commodity for every entrepreneur. With all the responsibilities of managing and growing a small business, the hours and the days can easily slip by, sometimes leaving one to wonder just how much got accomplished.
ISU to host conference about careers in tech fields
High school and college students can learn about technology and engineering-related careers during a conference at Indiana State University.
On the move: March 30, 2014
Diane C. Smith was recently promoted to commercial loan operations manager and officer at First Financial Bank. She works from the Main Office Banking Center at 1 First Financial Plaza in downtown Terre Haute.
Old National Bank noted for ethics
The Ethisphere Institute recognized Old National Bank as a 2014 World’s Most Ethical Company. Ethisphere is an independent center of research promoting best practices in corporate ethics and governance.
- More Business Headlines
- EYE ON THE PIE: Necessary truth: Reality not built on press releases